• Eric Sandeen's avatar
    ext4: don't scan/accumulate more pages than mballoc will allocate · c445e3e0
    Eric Sandeen authored
    There was a bug reported on RHEL5 that a 10G dd on a 12G box
    had a very, very slow sync after that.
    
    At issue was the loop in write_cache_pages scanning all the way
    to the end of the 10G file, even though the subsequent call
    to mpage_da_submit_io would only actually write a smallish amt; then
    we went back to the write_cache_pages loop ... wasting tons of time
    in calling __mpage_da_writepage for thousands of pages we would
    just revisit (many times) later.
    
    Upstream it's not such a big issue for sys_sync because we get
    to the loop with a much smaller nr_to_write, which limits the loop.
    
    However, talking with Aneesh he realized that fsync upstream still
    gets here with a very large nr_to_write and we face the same problem.
    
    This patch makes mpage_add_bh_to_extent stop the loop after we've
    accumulated 2048 pages, by setting mpd->io_done = 1; which ultimately
    causes the write_cache_pages loop to break.
    
    Repeating the test with a dirty_ratio of 80 (to leave something for
    fsync to do), I don't see huge IO performance gains, but the reduction
    in cpu usage is striking: 80% usage with stock, and 2% with the
    below patch.  Instrumenting the loop in write_cache_pages clearly
    shows that we are wasting time here.
    
    Eventually we need to change mpage_da_map_pages() also submit its I/O
    to the block layer, subsuming mpage_da_submit_io(), and then change it
    call ext4_get_blocks() multiple times.
    Signed-off-by: default avatarEric Sandeen <sandeen@redhat.com>
    Signed-off-by: default avatar"Theodore Ts'o" <tytso@mit.edu>
    c445e3e0
inode.c 174 KB