Merge branch 'riyad-discussions'

app/assets/javascripts/behaviors/details_behavior.coffee

+$ ->
+  $("body").on "click", ".js-details-target", ->
+    container = $(@).closest(".js-details-container")
+
+    container.toggleClass("open")

app/assets/javascripts/behaviors/toggler_behavior.coffee

+$ ->
+  $("body").on "click", ".js-toggler-target", ->
+    container = $(@).closest(".js-toggler-container")
+
+    container.toggleClass("on")

app/assets/javascripts/extensions/array.js

+Array.prototype.first = function() {
+  return this[0];
+}
+
+Array.prototype.last = function() {
+  return this[this.length-1];
+}
\ No newline at end of file

app/assets/stylesheets/application.scss

@@ -46,3 +46,8 @@
 @import "themes/ui_gray.scss";
 @import "themes/ui_color.scss";
 
+/**
+ * Styles for JS behaviors.
+ */
+@import "behaviors.scss";
+

app/assets/stylesheets/behaviors.scss

+// Details
+//--------
+.js-details-container .content { display: none; }
+.js-details-container .content.hide { display: block; }
+.js-details-container.open .content { display: block; }
+.js-details-container.open .content.hide { display: none; }
+
+
+// Toggler
+//--------
+.js-toggler-container .turn-on  { display: inherit; }
+.js-toggler-container .turn-off { display: none; }
+.js-toggler-container.on .turn-on  { display: none; }
+.js-toggler-container.on .turn-off { display: inherit; }

app/assets/stylesheets/common.scss

@@ -546,3 +546,9 @@ h1.http_status_code {
     }
   }
 }
+
+img.emoji {
+  height: 20px;
+  vertical-align: middle;
+  width: 20px;
+}

app/assets/stylesheets/sections/commits.scss

@@ -119,12 +119,14 @@
       }
     }
   }
-  .old_line, .new_line {
-    margin: 0px;
-    padding: 0px;
-    border: none;
-    background: #EEE;
-    color: #666;
+  .new_line,
+  .old_line,
+  .notes_line {
+    margin:0px;
+    padding:0px;
+    border:none;
+    background:#EEE;
+    color:#666;
     padding: 0px 5px;
     border-right: 1px solid #ccc;
     text-align: right;
@@ -134,6 +136,7 @@
     moz-user-select: none;
     -khtml-user-select: none;
     user-select: none;
+
     a {
       float: left;
       width: 35px;

app/assets/stylesheets/sections/notes.scss

 /**
  * Notes
- *
  */
-#notes-list,
-#new-notes-list {
+ul.notes {
   display: block;
   list-style: none;
   margin: 0px;
   padding: 0px;
-}
 
-.issue_notes,
-.wiki_notes {
-  .note_content {
+  .discussion-header,
+  .note-header {
+    @extend .cgray;
+    padding-top: 5px;
+    padding-bottom: 15px;
+
+    .avatar {
       float: left;
-    width: 400px;
+      margin-right: 10px;
     }
-}
 
-/* Note textare */
-#note_note {
-  height: 80px;
-  width: 98%;
-  font-size: 14px;
-}
+    .discussion-last-update,
+    .note-last-update {
+      font-style: italic;
+    }
+    .note-author {
+      color: $style_color;
+      font-weight: bold;
+      &:hover {
+        color: $primary_color;
+      }
+    }
+  }
 
-#new_note {
-  .attach_holder {
-    display: none;
+  .discussion {
+    padding: 8px 0;
+    overflow: hidden;
+    display: block;
+    position:relative;
+
+    .discussion-body {
+      margin-left: 50px;
+
+      .diff_file,
+      .discussion-hidden,
+      .notes {
+        @extend .borders;
+        background-color: #F9F9F9;
       }
-}
+      .diff_file .notes {
+        /* reset */
+        background: inherit;
+        border: none;
+        @include box-shadow(none);
 
-.preview_note {
-  margin: 2px;
-  border: 1px solid #ddd;
-  padding: 10px;
-  min-height: 60px;
-  background: #f5f5f5;
-}
+      }
+      .discussion-hidden .note {
+        @extend .cgray;
+        padding: 8px;
+        text-align: center;
+      }
+      .notes .note {
+        border-color: #ddd;
+        padding: 8px;
+      }
+      .reply-btn {
+        margin-top: 8px;
+      }
+    }
+  }
 
-.note {
+  .note {
     padding: 8px 0;
     overflow: hidden;
     display: block;
-  position: relative;
-  img {float: left; margin-right: 10px;}
-  img.emoji {float: none;margin: 0;}
-  .note-author cite{font-style: italic;}
+    position:relative;
     p { color: $style_color; }
-  .note-author { color: $style_color;}
 
-  .note-title { margin-left: 45px; padding-top: 5px;}
     .avatar {
       margin-top: 3px;
     }
+    .attachment {
+      font-size: 14px;
+      margin-top: -20px;
 
-  .delete-note {
-    display: none;
-    position: absolute;
-    right: 0;
-    top: 0;
+      .icon-attachment {
+        @extend .icon-paper-clip;
+        font-size: 24px;
+        position: relative;
+        text-align: right;
+        top: 6px;
       }
-
-  &:hover {
-    .delete-note { display: block; }
     }
-}
-#notes-list:not(.reversed) .note,
-#new-notes-list:not(.reversed) .note {
+    .note-body {
+      margin-left: 45px;
+    }
+    .note-header {
+      padding-bottom: 5px;
+    }
+  }
+
+  // paint top or bottom borders depending on notes direction
+  &:not(.reversed) .note,
+  &:not(.reversed) .discussion {
     border-bottom: 1px solid #eee;
-}
-#notes-list.reversed .note,
-#new-notes-list.reversed .note {
+  }
+  &.reversed .note,
+  &.reversed .discussion {
     border-top: 1px solid #eee;
+  }
 }
 
-/* mark vote notes */
-.voting_notes .note {
-  padding: 8px 0;
-}
+.diff_file .notes_holder {
+  font-family: $sansFontFamily;
+  font-size: 13px;
+  line-height: 18px;
 
-.notes-status {
-  margin: 18px;
-}
+  td {
+    border: 1px solid #ddd;
+    border-left: none;
 
+    &.notes_line {
+      text-align: center;
+      padding: 10px 0;
+    }
+    &.notes_content {
+      background-color: $white;
+      border-width: 1px 0;
+      padding-top: 0;
+    }
+  }
 
-p.notify_controls input{
-  margin: 5px;
+  .reply-btn {
+    margin-top: 8px;
+  }
 }
 
-p.notify_controls span{
-  font-weight: 700;
-}
 
-tr.line_notes_row {
-  border-bottom: 1px solid #DDD;
-  border-left: 7px solid #2A79A3;
 
-  &.reply {
-    background: #eee;
-    border-left: 7px solid #2A79A3;
-    border-top: 1px solid #ddd;
-    td {
-      padding: 7px 10px;
-    }
-    a.line_note_reply_link {
-      border: 1px solid #eaeaea;
-      @include border-radius(4px);
-      padding: 3px 10px;
-      margin-left: 5px;
-      color: white;
-      background: #2A79A3;
-      border-color: #2A79A3;
-    }
-  }
-  ul {
-    margin: 0;
-    li {
-      padding: 0;
-      border: none;
+/**
+ * Actions for Discussions/Notes
+ */
+
+.discussion,
+.note {
+  &.note:hover {
+    .note-actions { display: block; }
   }
+  .discussion-header:hover {
+    .discussion-actions { display: block; }
   }
-}
 
-.line_notes_row,  .per_line_form { font-family: "Helvetica Neue", Helvetica, Arial, sans-serif; }
+  .discussion-actions,
+  .note-actions {
+    display: none;
+    float: right;
 
-.per_line_form {
-  background: #f5f5f5;
-  border-top: 1px solid #eee;
-  form {  margin: 0; }
-  td {
-    border-bottom: 1px solid #ddd;
+    [class^="icon-"],
+    [class*="icon-"] {
+      font-size: 16px;
+      line-height: 16px;
+      vertical-align: middle;
     }
-  .note_actions {
-    margin: 0;
-    padding-top: 10px;
 
-    .buttons {
-      float: left;
-      width: 300px;
-    }
-    .options {
-      .labels {
-        float: left;
-        padding-left: 10px;
-        label {
-          padding: 6px 0;
-          margin: 0;
-          width: 120px;
-        }
+    a {
+      @extend .cgray;
+
+      &:hover {
+        color: $primary_color;
+        &.danger { @extend .cred; }
       }
     }
   }
 }
+.diff_file .note .note-actions {
+  right: 0;
+  top: 0;
+}
+
+
+
+/**
+ * Line note button on the side of diffs
+ */
 
-td .line_note_link {
+.diff_file tr.line_holder {
+  .add-diff-note {
+    background: url("diff_note_add.png") no-repeat left 0;
+    height: 22px;
+    margin-left: -65px;
     position: absolute;
-  margin-left:-70px;
-  margin-top:-10px;
+    width: 22px;
     z-index: 10;
-  background: url("comment_add.png") no-repeat left 0;
-  width: 32px;
-  height: 32px;
 
+    // "hide" it by default
     opacity: 0.0;
     filter: alpha(opacity=0);
 
@@ -170,64 +199,116 @@ td .line_note_link {
       opacity: 1.0;
       filter: alpha(opacity=100);
     }
-}
+  }
+
+  // "show" the icon also if we just hover somwhere over the line
+  &:hover > td {
+    background: $hover !important;
 
-.diff_file_content tr.line_holder:hover > td { background: $hover !important; }
-.diff_file_content tr.line_holder:hover > td .line_note_link {
+    .add-diff-note {
       opacity: 1.0;
       filter: alpha(opacity=100);
+    }
+  }
 }
 
-.new_note {
-  .input-file {
-    font: 500px monospace;
-    opacity: 0;
-    filter: alpha(opacity=0);
-    position: absolute;
-    z-index: 1;
-    top: 0;
-    right: 0;
-    padding: 0;
-    margin: 0;
+
+
+/**
+ * Note Form
+ */
+
+.comment-btn,
+.reply-btn {
+  @extend .save-btn;
+}
+.diff_file,
+.discussion {
+  .new_note {
+    margin: 8px 5px 8px 0;
+
+    .note_options {
+      // because of the smaller width and the extra "cancel" button
+      margin-top: 8px;
+    }
   }
+}
+.new_note {
+  display: none;
 
-  .note_advanced_opts {
+  .buttons {
+    float: left;
+    margin-top: 8px;
+  }
+  .clearfix {
+    margin-bottom: 0;
+  }
+  .note_options {
     h6 {
-      line-height: 32px;
-      padding-right: 15px;
+      @extend .left;
+      line-height: 20px;
+      padding-right: 16px;
+      padding-bottom: 16px;
     }
+    label {
+      padding: 0;
     }
 
-  .attachments {
+    .attachment {
+      @extend .right;
       position: relative;
       width: 350px;
       height: 50px;
-    overflow: hidden;
       margin:0 0 5px !important;
 
-    .input_file {
-      .file_upload {
-        position: absolute;
-        right: 14px;
-        top: 7px;
+      // hide the actual file field
+      input {
+        display: none;
       }
 
-      .file_name {
-        line-height: 30px;
-        width: 240px;
-        height: 28px;
-        overflow: hidden;
-      }
-      .input-file {
-        width: 260px;
-        height: 41px;
+      .choose-btn {
         float: right;
       }
     }
+    .notify_options {
+      @extend .right;
     }
-}
+  }
+  .note_text_and_preview {
+    // makes the "absolute" position for links relative to this
+    position: relative;
 
-.note-text {
+    // preview/edit buttons
+    > a {
+      font-size: 24px;
+      padding: 4px;
+      position: absolute;
+      right: 10px;
+    }
+    .note_preview {
+      background: #f5f5f5;
+      border: 1px solid #ddd;
+      @include border-radius(4px);
+      min-height: 80px;
+      padding: 4px 6px;
+    }
+    .note_text {
       border: 1px solid #DDD;
       box-shadow: none;
+      font-size: 14px;
+      height: 80px;
+      width: 98.6%;
+    }
+  }
+}
+
+/* loading indicator */
+.notes-busy {
+  margin: 18px;
+}
+
+.note-image-attach {
+  @extend .span4;
+  @extend .thumbnail;
+  margin-left: 45px;
 }

app/contexts/notes/create_context.rb

@@ -3,8 +3,8 @@ module Notes
     def execute
       note = project.notes.new(params[:note])
       note.author = current_user
-      note.notify = true if params[:notify] == '1'
-      note.notify_author = true if params[:notify_author] == '1'
+      note.notify = params[:notify].present?
+      note.notify_author = params[:notify_author].present?
       note.save
       note
     end

app/contexts/notes/load_context.rb

@@ -9,11 +9,11 @@ module Notes
 
       @notes = case target_type
                when "commit"
-                 project.notes.for_commit_id(target_id).not_inline.fresh.limit(20)
+                 project.notes.for_commit_id(target_id).not_inline.fresh
                when "issue"
-                 project.issues.find(target_id).notes.inc_author.fresh.limit(20)
+                 project.issues.find(target_id).notes.inc_author.fresh
                when "merge_request"
-                 project.merge_requests.find(target_id).mr_and_commit_notes.inc_author.fresh.limit(20)
+                 project.merge_requests.find(target_id).mr_and_commit_notes.inc_author.fresh
                when "snippet"
                  project.snippets.find(target_id).notes.fresh
                when "wall"

app/controllers/commit_controller.rb

@@ -14,10 +14,16 @@ class CommitController < ProjectResourceController
     git_not_found! unless @commit
 
     @suppress_diff = result[:suppress_diff]
+
     @note        = result[:note]
     @line_notes  = result[:line_notes]
     @notes_count = result[:notes_count]
-    @comments_allowed = true
+    @target_type = :commit
+    @target_id   = @commit.id
+
+    @comments_allowed = @reply_allowed = true
+    @comments_target  = { noteable_type: 'Commit',
+                          commit_id: @commit.id }
 
     respond_to do |format|
       format.html do

app/controllers/issues_controller.rb

@@ -35,6 +35,8 @@ class IssuesController < ProjectResourceController
 
   def show
     @note = @project.notes.new(noteable: @issue)
+    @target_type = :issue
+    @target_id = @issue.id
 
     respond_to do |format|
       format.html

app/controllers/merge_requests_controller.rb

@@ -18,6 +18,9 @@ class MergeRequestsController < ProjectResourceController
   end
 
   def show
+    @target_type = :merge_request
+    @target_id = @merge_request.id
+
     respond_to do |format|
       format.html
       format.js
@@ -31,7 +34,9 @@ class MergeRequestsController < ProjectResourceController
     @diffs = @merge_request.diffs
     @commit = @merge_request.last_commit
 
-    @comments_allowed = true
+    @comments_allowed = @reply_allowed = true
+    @comments_target  = { noteable_type: 'MergeRequest',
+                          noteable_id: @merge_request.id }
     @line_notes = @merge_request.notes.where("line_code is not null")
   end
 

app/controllers/notes_controller.rb

@@ -6,10 +6,12 @@ class NotesController < ProjectResourceController
   respond_to :js
 
   def index
-    notes
+    @notes = Notes::LoadContext.new(project, current_user, params).execute
+    @target_type = params[:target_type].camelize
+    @target_id = params[:target_id]
+
     if params[:target_type] == "merge_request"
-      @mixed_targets = true
-      @main_target_type = params[:target_type].camelize
+      @discussions   = discussions_from_notes
     end
 
     respond_with(@notes)
@@ -17,6 +19,8 @@ class NotesController < ProjectResourceController
 
   def create
     @note = Notes::CreateContext.new(project, current_user, params).execute
+    @target_type = params[:target_type].camelize
+    @target_id = params[:target_id]
 
     respond_to do |format|
       format.html {redirect_to :back}
@@ -40,7 +44,34 @@ class NotesController < ProjectResourceController
 
   protected
 
-  def notes
-    @notes = Notes::LoadContext.new(project, current_user, params).execute
+  def discussion_notes_for(note)
+    @notes.select do |other_note|
+      note.discussion_id == other_note.discussion_id
+    end
+  end
+
+  def discussions_from_notes
+    discussion_ids = []
+    discussions = []
+
+    @notes.each do |note|
+      next if discussion_ids.include?(note.discussion_id)
+
+      # don't group notes for the main target
+      if note_for_main_target?(note)
+        discussions << [note]
+      else
+        discussions << discussion_notes_for(note)
+        discussion_ids << note.discussion_id
+      end
+    end
+
+    discussions
+  end
+
+  # Helps to distinguish e.g. commit notes in mr notes list
+  def note_for_main_target?(note)
+    note.for_wall? ||
+      (@target_type.camelize == note.noteable_type && !note.for_diff_line?)
   end
 end

app/controllers/projects_controller.rb

@@ -80,7 +80,10 @@ class ProjectsController < ProjectResourceController
 
   def wall
     return render_404 unless @project.wall_enabled
-    @note = Note.new
+
+    @target_type = :wall
+    @target_id = nil
+    @note = @project.notes.new
 
     respond_to do |format|
       format.html

app/controllers/snippets_controller.rb

@@ -50,6 +50,8 @@ class SnippetsController < ProjectResourceController
 
   def show
     @note = @project.notes.new(noteable: @snippet)
+    @target_type = :snippet
+    @target_id = @snippet.id
   end
 
   def destroy

app/helpers/commits_helper.rb

@@ -9,11 +9,13 @@ module CommitsHelper
     end
   end
 
-  def build_line_anchor(index, line_new, line_old)
-    "#{index}_#{line_old}_#{line_new}"
+  def build_line_anchor(diff, line_new, line_old)
+    "#{hexdigest(diff.new_path)}_#{line_old}_#{line_new}"
   end
 
-  def each_diff_line(diff_arr, index)
+  def each_diff_line(diff, index)
+    diff_arr = diff.diff.lines.to_a
+
     line_old = 1
     line_new = 1
     type = nil
@@ -39,7 +41,7 @@ module CommitsHelper
         next
       else
         type = identification_type(line)
-        line_code = build_line_anchor(index, line_new, line_old)
+        line_code = build_line_anchor(diff, line_new, line_old)
         yield(full_line, type, line_code, line_new, line_old)
       end
 

app/helpers/notes_helper.rb

 module NotesHelper
-  def loading_more_notes?
-    params[:loading_more].present?
+   # Helps to distinguish e.g. commit notes in mr notes list
+  def note_for_main_target?(note)
+    note.for_wall? ||
+      (@target_type.camelize == note.noteable_type && !note.for_diff_line?)
   end
 
-  def loading_new_notes?
-    params[:loading_new].present?
+  def note_target_fields
+    hidden_field_tag(:target_type, @target_type) +
+    hidden_field_tag(:target_id, @target_id)
   end
 
-   # Helps to distinguish e.g. commit notes in mr notes list
-  def note_for_main_target?(note)
-    !@mixed_targets || @main_target_type == note.noteable_type
+  def link_to_commit_diff_line_note(note)
+    if note.for_commit_diff_line?
+      link_to "#{note.diff_file_name}:L#{note.diff_new_line}", project_commit_path(@project, note.noteable, anchor: note.line_code)
+    end
   end
 
-  def link_to_commit_diff_line_note(note)
-    commit = note.noteable
-    diff_index, diff_old_line, diff_new_line = note.line_code.split('_')
+  def link_to_merge_request_diff_line_note(note)
+    if note.for_merge_request_diff_line? and note.diff
+      link_to "#{note.diff_file_name}:L#{note.diff_new_line}", diffs_project_merge_request_path(note.project, note.noteable_id, anchor: note.line_code)
+    end
+  end
 
-    link_file = commit.diffs[diff_index.to_i].new_path
-    link_line = diff_new_line
+  def loading_more_notes?
+    params[:loading_more].present?
+  end
 
-    link_to "#{link_file}:L#{link_line}", project_commit_path(@project, commit, anchor: note.line_code)
+  def loading_new_notes?
+    params[:loading_new].present?
   end
 end

app/mailers/notify.rb

@@ -63,12 +63,12 @@ class Notify < ActionMailer::Base
   # Note
   #
 
-  def note_commit_email(recipient_id, note_id)
+  def note_commit_email(commit_autor_email, note_id)
     @note = Note.find(note_id)
     @commit = @note.noteable
     @commit = CommitDecorator.decorate(@commit)
     @project = @note.project
-    mail(to: recipient(recipient_id), subject: subject("note for commit #{@commit.short_id}", @commit.title))
+    mail(to: recipient(commit_autor_email), subject: subject("note for commit #{@commit.short_id}", @commit.title))
   end
 
   def note_issue_email(recipient_id, note_id)

app/models/concerns/issuable.rb

@@ -69,29 +69,33 @@ module Issuable
     closed_changed? && !closed
   end
 
-  # Return the number of +1 comments (upvotes)
-  def upvotes
-    notes.select(&:upvote?).size
+  #
+  # Votes
+  #
+
+  # Return the number of -1 comments (downvotes)
+  def downvotes
+    notes.select(&:downvote?).size
   end
 
-  def upvotes_in_percent
+  def downvotes_in_percent
     if votes_count.zero?
       0
     else
-      100.0 / votes_count * upvotes
+      100.0 - upvotes_in_percent
     end
   end
 
-  # Return the number of -1 comments (downvotes)
-  def downvotes
-    notes.select(&:downvote?).size
+  # Return the number of +1 comments (upvotes)
+  def upvotes
+    notes.select(&:upvote?).size
   end
 
-  def downvotes_in_percent
+  def upvotes_in_percent
     if votes_count.zero?
       0
     else
-      100.0 - upvotes_in_percent
+      100.0 / votes_count * upvotes
     end
   end
 

app/models/note.rb

@@ -19,7 +19,6 @@ require 'carrierwave/orm/activerecord'
 require 'file_size_validator'
 
 class Note < ActiveRecord::Base
-
   attr_accessible :note, :noteable, :noteable_id, :noteable_type, :project_id,
                   :attachment, :line_code, :commit_id
 
@@ -34,6 +33,7 @@ class Note < ActiveRecord::Base
   delegate :name, :email, to: :author, prefix: true
 
   validates :note, :project, presence: true
+  validates :line_code, format: { with: /\A[a-z0-9]+_\d+_\d+\Z/ }, allow_blank: true
   validates :attachment, file_size: { maximum: 10.megabytes.to_i }
 
   validates :noteable_id, presence: true, if: ->(n) { n.noteable_type.present? && n.noteable_type != 'Commit' }
@@ -60,71 +60,107 @@ class Note < ActiveRecord::Base
     }, without_protection: true)
   end
 
-  def notify
-    @notify ||= false
+  def commit_author
+    @commit_author ||=
+      project.users.find_by_email(noteable.author_email) ||
+      project.users.find_by_name(noteable.author_name)
+  rescue
+    nil
   end
 
-  def notify_author
-    @notify_author ||= false
+  def diff
+    if noteable.diffs.present?
+      noteable.diffs.select do |d|
+        if d.b_path
+          Digest::SHA1.hexdigest(d.b_path) == diff_file_index
+        end
+      end.first
+    end
   end
 
-  # override to return commits, which are not active record
-  def noteable
-    if for_commit?
-      project.repository.commit(commit_id)
-    else
-      super
+  def diff_file_index
+    line_code.split('_')[0]
   end
-  # Temp fix to prevent app crash
-  # if note commit id doesnt exist
-  rescue
-    nil
+
+  def diff_file_name
+    diff.b_path
+  end
+
+  def diff_new_line
+    line_code.split('_')[2].to_i
+  end
+
+  def discussion_id
+    @discussion_id ||= [:discussion, noteable_type.try(:underscore), noteable_id, line_code].join("-").to_sym
   end
 
-  # Check if we can notify commit author
-  # with email about our comment
-  #
-  # If commit author email exist in project
-  # and commit author is not passed user we can
-  # send email to him
-  #
-  # params:
-  #   user - current user
-  #
-  # return:
-  #   Boolean
-  #
-  def notify_only_author?(user)
-    for_commit? && commit_author &&
-      commit_author.email != user.email
+  # Returns true if this is a downvote note,
+  # otherwise false is returned
+  def downvote?
+    votable? && (note.start_with?('-1') ||
+                 note.start_with?(':-1:')
+                )
   end
 
   def for_commit?
     noteable_type == "Commit"
   end
 
+  def for_commit_diff_line?
+    for_commit? && for_diff_line?
+  end
+
   def for_diff_line?
     line_code.present?
   end
 
-  def commit_author
-    @commit_author ||=
-      project.users.find_by_email(noteable.author_email) ||
-      project.users.find_by_name(noteable.author_name)
+  def for_issue?
+    noteable_type == "Issue"
+  end
+
+  def for_merge_request?
+    noteable_type == "MergeRequest"
+  end
+
+  def for_merge_request_diff_line?
+    for_merge_request? && for_diff_line?
+  end
+
+  def for_wall?
+    noteable_type.blank?
+  end
+
+  # override to return commits, which are not active record
+  def noteable
+    if for_commit?
+      project.repository.commit(commit_id)
+    else
+      super
+    end
+  # Temp fix to prevent app crash
+  # if note commit id doesnt exist
   rescue
     nil
   end
 
+  def notify
+    @notify ||= false
+  end
+
+  def notify_author
+    @notify_author ||= false
+  end
+
   # Returns true if this is an upvote note,
   # otherwise false is returned
   def upvote?
-    note.start_with?('+1') || note.start_with?(':+1:')
+    votable? && (note.start_with?('+1') ||
+                 note.start_with?(':+1:')
+                )
   end
 
-  # Returns true if this is a downvote note,
-  # otherwise false is returned
-  def downvote?
-    note.start_with?('-1') || note.start_with?(':-1:')
+  def votable?
+    for_issue? || (for_merge_request? && !for_diff_line?)
   end
 
   def noteable_type_name

app/observers/note_observer.rb

@@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ class NoteObserver < ActiveRecord::Observer
       notify_team(note)
     elsif note.notify_author
       # Notify only author of resource
-      Notify.delay.note_commit_email(note.commit_author.id, note.id)
+      Notify.delay.note_commit_email(note.noteable.author_email, note.id)
     else
       # Otherwise ignore it
       nil

app/views/commit/show.html.haml

@@ -7,12 +7,10 @@
   %span.cred #{@commit.stats.deletions} deletions
 
 = render "commits/diffs", diffs: @commit.diffs
-= render "notes/notes_with_form", tid: @commit.id, tt: "commit"
-= render "notes/per_line_form"
+= render "notes/notes_with_form"
 
 :javascript
   $(function(){
-    PerLineNotes.init();
     var w, h;
     $('.diff_file').each(function(){
       $('.image.diff_removed img', this).on('load', $.proxy(function(event){

app/views/commits/_diffs.html.haml

@@ -38,10 +38,10 @@
 
         %br/
       .diff_file_content
-        -# Skipp all non non-supported blobs
+        -# Skip all non-supported blobs
         - next unless file.respond_to?('text?')
         - if file.text?
-          = render "commits/text_file", diff: diff, index: i
+          = render "commits/text_diff", diff: diff, index: i
         - elsif file.image?
           - old_file = (@commit.prev_commit.tree / diff.old_path) if !@commit.prev_commit.nil?
           - if diff.renamed_file || diff.new_file || diff.deleted_file

app/views/commits/_text_file.html.haml → app/views/commits/_text_diff.html.haml

@@ -3,7 +3,7 @@
   %a.supp_diff_link Diff suppressed. Click to show
 
 %table{class: "#{'hide' if too_big}"}
-  - each_diff_line(diff.diff.lines.to_a, index) do |line, type, line_code, line_new, line_old|
+  - each_diff_line(diff, index) do |line, type, line_code, line_new, line_old|
     %tr.line_holder{ id: line_code }
       - if type == "match"
         %td.old_line= "..."
@@ -13,11 +13,11 @@
         %td.old_line
           = link_to raw(type == "new" ? " " : line_old), "##{line_code}", id: line_code
           - if @comments_allowed
-            = render "notes/per_line_note_link", line_code: line_code
+            = render "notes/diff_note_link", line_code: line_code
         %td.new_line= link_to raw(type == "old" ? " " : line_new) , "##{line_code}", id: line_code
         %td.line_content{class: "noteable_line #{type} #{line_code}", "line_code" => line_code}= raw diff_line_content(line)
 
-        - if @comments_allowed
+    - if @reply_allowed
       - comments = @line_notes.select { |n| n.line_code == line_code }.sort_by(&:created_at)
       - unless comments.empty?
-            = render "notes/per_line_notes_with_reply", notes: comments
+        = render "notes/diff_notes_with_reply", notes: comments

app/views/issues/show.html.haml

@@ -56,4 +56,4 @@
           = markdown @issue.description
 
 
-.issue_notes.voting_notes#notes= render "notes/notes_with_form", tid: @issue.id, tt: "issue"
+.voting_notes#notes= render "notes/notes_with_form"

app/views/merge_requests/_show.html.haml

@@ -12,20 +12,18 @@
       %li.notes-tab{data: {action: 'notes'}}
         = link_to project_merge_request_path(@project, @merge_request) do
           %i.icon-comment
-          Comments
+          Discussion
       %li.diffs-tab{data: {action: 'diffs'}}
         = link_to diffs_project_merge_request_path(@project, @merge_request) do
           %i.icon-list-alt
           Diff
 
   .notes.tab-content.voting_notes#notes{ class: (controller.action_name == 'show') ? "" : "hide" }
-    = render("notes/notes_with_form", tid: @merge_request.id, tt: "merge_request")
+    = render "notes/notes_with_form"
   .diffs.tab-content
     = render "merge_requests/show/diffs" if @diffs
   .status
 
-  = render "notes/per_line_form"
-
 :javascript
   var merge_request;
   $(function(){

app/views/merge_requests/diffs.html.haml

 = render "show"
-
-:javascript
-  $(function(){
-    PerLineNotes.init();
-  });

app/views/merge_requests/diffs.js.haml

 :plain
   merge_request.$(".diffs").html("#{escape_javascript(render(partial: "merge_requests/show/diffs"))}");
-
-  PerLineNotes.init();
-

app/views/merge_requests/show.js.haml

 :plain
-  merge_request.$(".notes").html("#{escape_javascript(render "notes/notes_with_form", tid: @merge_request.id, tt: "merge_request")}");
+  merge_request.$(".notes").html("#{escape_javascript(render "notes/notes_with_form")}");

app/views/notes/_common_form.html.haml

-.note-form-holder
-  = form_for [@project, @note], remote: "true", multipart: true do |f|
-    %h3.page_title Leave a comment
-    -if @note.errors.any?
-      .alert-message.block-message.error
-        - @note.errors.full_messages.each do |msg|
-          %div= msg
-
-    = f.hidden_field :noteable_id
-    = f.hidden_field :commit_id
-    = f.hidden_field :noteable_type
-    = f.text_area :note, size: 255, class: 'note-text js-gfm-input'
-    #preview-note.preview_note.hide
-    .hint
-      .right Comments are parsed with #{link_to "GitLab Flavored Markdown", help_markdown_path, target: '_blank'}.
-      .clearfix
-
-    .row.note_advanced_opts
-      .span3
-        = f.submit 'Add Comment', class: "btn success submit_note grouped", id: "submit_note"
-        = link_to 'Preview', preview_project_notes_path(@project), class: 'btn grouped', id: 'preview-link'
-      .span4.notify_opts
-        %h6.left Notify via email:
-        = label_tag :notify do
-          = check_box_tag :notify, 1, @note.noteable_type != "Commit"
-          %span Project team
-
-        - if @note.notify_only_author?(current_user)
-          = label_tag :notify_author do
-            = check_box_tag :notify_author, 1 , @note.noteable_type == "Commit"
-            %span Commit author
-      .span5.attachments
-        %h6.left Attachment:
-        %span.file_name File name...
-
-        .input.input_file
-          %a.file_upload.btn.small Upload File
-          = f.file_field :attachment, class: "input-file"
-        %span.hint Any file less than 10 MB

app/views/notes/_create_common_note.js.haml

-- if note.valid?
-  :plain
-    $(".note-form-holder .error").remove();
-    $('.note-form-holder textarea').val("");
-    $('.note-form-holder #preview-link').text('Preview');
-    $('.note-form-holder #preview-note').hide();
-    $('.note-form-holder').show();
-    NoteList.appendNewNote(#{note.id}, "#{escape_javascript(render "notes/note", note: note)}");
-
-- else
-  :plain
-    $(".note-form-holder").replaceWith("#{escape_javascript(render 'notes/common_form')}");
-    GitLab.GfmAutoComplete.setup();

app/views/notes/_create_per_line_note.js.haml

-- if note.valid?
-  :plain
-    // hide and reset the form
-    $(".per_line_form").hide();
-    $('.line-note-form-holder textarea').val("");
-
-    // find the reply button for this line
-    // (might not be there if this is the first note)
-    var trRpl = $("a.line_note_reply_link[data-line-code='#{note.line_code}']").closest("tr");
-    if (trRpl.size() == 0) {
-      // find the commented line ...
-      var trEl = $(".#{note.line_code}").parent();
-      // ... and insert the note and the reply button after it
-      trEl.after("#{escape_javascript(render "notes/per_line_reply_button", line_code: note.line_code)}");
-      trEl.after("#{escape_javascript(render "notes/per_line_note", note: note)}");
-    } else {
-      // instert new note before reply button
-      trRpl.before("#{escape_javascript(render "notes/per_line_note", note: note)}");
-    }

app/views/notes/_diff_note_link.html.haml

+- note = @project.notes.new(@comments_target.merge({ line_code: line_code }))
+= link_to "",
+          "javascript:;",
+          class: "add-diff-note js-add-diff-note-button",
+          data: { noteable_type: note.noteable_type,
+                  noteable_id:   note.noteable_id,
+                  commit_id:     note.commit_id,
+                  line_code:     note.line_code,
+                  discussion_id: note.discussion_id },
+          title: "Add a comment to this line"

app/views/notes/_diff_notes_with_reply.html.haml

+- note = notes.first # example note
+%tr.notes_holder
+  %td.notes_line{ colspan: 2 }
+    %span.btn.disabled
+      %i.icon-comment
+      = notes.count
+  %td.notes_content
+    %ul.notes{ rel: note.discussion_id }
+      = render notes
+
+    = render "notes/discussion_reply_button", note: note

app/views/notes/_discussion.html.haml

+- note = discussion_notes.first
+.discussion.js-details-container.js-toggler-container.open{ class: note.discussion_id }
+  .discussion-header
+    .discussion-actions
+      = link_to "javascript:;", class: "js-details-target turn-on js-toggler-target" do
+        %i.icon-eye-close
+        Hide discussion
+      = link_to "javascript:;", class: "js-details-target turn-off js-toggler-target" do
+        %i.icon-eye-open
+        Show discussion
+    = image_tag gravatar_icon(note.author.email), class: "avatar s32"
+    %div
+      = link_to note.author_name, project_team_member_path(@project, @project.team_member_by_id(note.author)), class: "note-author"
+      - if note.for_merge_request?
+        - if note.diff
+          started a discussion on this merge request diff
+          = link_to_merge_request_diff_line_note(note)
+        - else
+          started
+          %strong
+            %i.icon-remove
+            outdated
+          discussion on this merge request diff
+      - elsif note.for_commit?
+        started a discussion on commit
+        #{link_to note.noteable.short_id, project_commit_path(@project, note.noteable)}
+        = link_to_commit_diff_line_note(note) if note.for_diff_line?
+      - else
+        %cite.cgray started a discussion
+    %div
+      - last_note = discussion_notes.last
+      last updated by
+      = link_to last_note.author_name, project_team_member_path(@project, @project.team_member_by_id(last_note.author)), class: "note-author"
+      %span.discussion-last-update
+        = time_ago_in_words(last_note.updated_at)
+        ago
+  .discussion-body
+    - if note.for_diff_line?
+      - if note.diff
+        .content
+          .diff_file= render "notes/discussion_diff", discussion_notes: discussion_notes, note: note
+      - else
+        = link_to 'show outdated discussion', '#', class: 'js-show-outdated-discussion'
+        %div.hide.outdated-discussion
+          .content
+            .notes{ rel: discussion_notes.first.discussion_id }
+              = render discussion_notes
+
+
+    - else
+      .content
+        .notes{ rel: discussion_notes.first.discussion_id }
+          = render discussion_notes
+        = render "notes/discussion_reply_button", note: discussion_notes.first
+
+    -# will be shown when the other one is hidden
+    .discussion-hidden.content.hide
+      .note
+        %em Hidden discussion.
+        = link_to "javascript:;", class: "js-details-target js-toggler-target" do
+          %i.icon-eye-open
+          Show
+

app/views/notes/_discussion_diff.html.haml

+- diff = note.diff
+.diff_file_header
+  - if diff.deleted_file
+    %span= diff.old_path
+  - else
+    %span= diff.new_path
+    - if diff.a_mode && diff.b_mode && diff.a_mode != diff.b_mode
+      %span.file-mode= "#{diff.a_mode} → #{diff.b_mode}"
+  %br/
+.diff_file_content
+  %table
+    - each_diff_line(diff, note.diff_file_index) do |line, type, line_code, line_new, line_old|
+      %tr.line_holder{ id: line_code }
+        - if type == "match"
+          %td.old_line= "..."
+          %td.new_line= "..."
+          %td.line_content.matched= line
+        - else
+          %td.old_line= raw(type == "new" ? " " : line_old)
+          %td.new_line= raw(type == "old" ? " " : line_new)
+          %td.line_content{class: "noteable_line #{type} #{line_code}", "line_code" => line_code}= raw "#{line}  "
+
+          - if line_code == note.line_code
+            = render "notes/diff_notes_with_reply", notes: discussion_notes
+            - break # cut off diff after notes

app/views/notes/_discussion_reply_button.html.haml

+= link_to "javascript:;",
+          class: "btn reply-btn js-discussion-reply-button",
+          data: { noteable_type: note.noteable_type,
+                  noteable_id:   note.noteable_id,
+                  commit_id:     note.commit_id,
+                  line_code:     note.line_code,
+                  discussion_id: note.discussion_id },
+          title: "Add a reply" do
+  %i.icon-comment
+  Reply

app/views/notes/_form.html.haml

+= form_for [@project, @note], remote: true, html: { multipart: true, id: nil, class: "new_note js-new-note-form" } do |f|
+
+  = note_target_fields
+  = f.hidden_field :commit_id
+  = f.hidden_field :line_code
+  = f.hidden_field :noteable_id
+  = f.hidden_field :noteable_type
+
+  .note_text_and_preview.js-toggler-container
+    %a.js-note-preview-button.js-toggler-target.turn-off{ href: "javascript:;", title: "Preview", data: {url: preview_project_notes_path(@project)} }
+      %i.icon-eye-open
+    %a.js-note-edit-button.js-toggler-target.turn-off{ href: "javascript:;", title: "Edit" }
+      %i.icon-edit
+
+    = f.text_area :note, size: 255, class: 'note_text js-note-text js-gfm-input turn-on'
+    .note_preview.js-note-preview.turn-off
+
+  .buttons
+    = f.submit 'Add Comment', class: "btn comment-btn grouped js-comment-button"
+    %a.btn.grouped.js-close-discussion-note-form Cancel
+  .hint
+    .right Comments are parsed with #{link_to "GitLab Flavored Markdown", help_markdown_path, target: '_blank'}.
+  .clearfix
+
+  .note_options
+    .attachment
+      %h6 Attachment:
+      .file_name.js-attachment-filename File name...
+      %a.choose-btn.btn.small.js-choose-note-attachment-button Choose File ...
+      .hint Any file up to 10 MB
+
+      = f.file_field :attachment, class: "js-note-attachment-input"
+
+    .notify_options
+      %h6 Notify via email:
+      = label_tag :notify do
+        = check_box_tag :notify, 1, !@note.for_commit?
+        Project team
+
+      .js-notify-commit-author
+        = label_tag :notify_author do
+          = check_box_tag :notify_author, 1 , @note.for_commit?
+          Commit author
+  .clearfix

app/views/notes/_form_errors.html.haml

+.error_message.js-errors
+  - note.errors.full_messages.each do |msg|
+    %div= msg

app/views/notes/_note.html.haml

-%li{id: dom_id(note), class: "note"}
-  = image_tag gravatar_icon(note.author.email), class: "avatar s32"
-  %div.note-author
-    %strong= note.author_name
+%li{ id: dom_id(note), class: dom_class(note), data: { discussion: note.discussion_id } }
+  .note-header
+    .note-actions
       = link_to "##{dom_id(note)}", name: dom_id(note) do
-      %cite.cgray
+        %i.icon-link
+        Link here
+       
+      - if(note.author_id == current_user.id) || can?(current_user, :admin_note, @project)
+        = link_to project_note_path(@project, note), title: "Remove comment", method: :delete, confirm: 'Are you sure you want to remove comment?', remote: true, class: "danger js-note-delete" do
+          %i.icon-trash.cred
+    = image_tag gravatar_icon(note.author.email), class: "avatar s32"
+    = link_to note.author_name, project_team_member_path(@project, @project.team_member_by_id(note.author)), class: "note-author"
+    %span.note-last-update
       = time_ago_in_words(note.updated_at)
       ago
 
-    - unless note_for_main_target?(note)
-      - if note.for_commit?
-        %span.cgray
-          on #{link_to note.noteable.short_id, project_commit_path(@project, note.noteable)}
-          = link_to_commit_diff_line_note(note) if note.for_diff_line?
-
-    -# only show vote if it's a note for the main target
-    - if note_for_main_target?(note)
     - if note.upvote?
       %span.vote.upvote.label.label-success
         %i.icon-thumbs-up
@@ -24,19 +23,15 @@
         %i.icon-thumbs-down
         \-1
 
-    -# remove button
-    - if(note.author_id == current_user.id) || can?(current_user, :admin_note, @project)
-      = link_to [@project, note], confirm: 'Are you sure?', method: :delete, remote: true, class: "cred delete-note btn very_small" do
-        %i.icon-trash
-        Remove
 
-  %div.note-title
+  .note-body
     = preserve do
       = markdown(note.note)
   - if note.attachment.url
     - if note.attachment.image?
-        = image_tag note.attachment.url, class: 'thumbnail span4'
-      .right
-        %div.file
-          = link_to note.attachment_identifier, note.attachment.url, target: "_blank"
+      = image_tag note.attachment.url, class: 'note-image-attach'
+    .attachment.right
+      = link_to note.attachment.url, target: "_blank" do
+        %i.icon-attachment
+        = note.attachment_identifier
   .clear

app/views/notes/_notes.html.haml

-- @notes.each do |note|
+- if @discussions.present?
+  - @discussions.each do |discussion_notes|
+    - note = discussion_notes.first
+    - if note_for_main_target?(note)
+      = render discussion_notes
+    - else
+      = render 'discussion', discussion_notes: discussion_notes
+- else
+  - @notes.each do |note|
     - next unless note.author
-  = render "note", note: note
-
+    = render 'note', note: note

app/views/notes/_notes_with_form.html.haml

-%ul#notes-list
-%ul#new-notes-list
-.notes-status
+%ul#notes-list.notes
+.js-notes-busy
 
+.js-main-target-form
 - if can? current_user, :write_note, @project
-  = render "notes/common_form"
+  = render "notes/form"
 
 :javascript
   $(function(){
-    NoteList.init("#{tid}", "#{tt}", "#{project_notes_path(@project)}");
+    NoteList.init("#{@target_id}", "#{@target_type}", "#{project_notes_path(@project)}");
   });

app/views/notes/_per_line_form.html.haml

-%table{style: "display:none;"}
-  %tr.per_line_form
-    %td{colspan: 3 }
-      .line-note-form-holder
-        = form_for [@project, @note], remote: "true", multipart: true do |f|
-          %h3.page_title Leave a note
-          %div.span10
-            -if @note.errors.any?
-              .alert-message.block-message.error
-                - @note.errors.full_messages.each do |msg|
-                  %div= msg
-
-            = f.hidden_field :noteable_id
-            = f.hidden_field :commit_id
-            = f.hidden_field :noteable_type
-            = f.hidden_field :line_code
-            = f.text_area :note,  size: 255, class: 'line-note-text js-gfm-input'
-            .note_actions
-              .buttons
-                = f.submit 'Add note', class: "btn save-btn submit_note submit_inline_note", id: "submit_note"
-                = link_to "Cancel", "#", class: "btn hide-button"
-              .options
-                %h6.left Notify via email:
-                .labels
-                  = label_tag :notify do
-                    = check_box_tag :notify, 1, @note.noteable_type != "Commit"
-                    %span Project team
-
-                  - if @note.notify_only_author?(current_user)
-                    = label_tag :notify_author do
-                      = check_box_tag :notify_author, 1 , @note.noteable_type == "Commit"
-                      %span Commit author
-
-:javascript
-  $(function(){
-    $(".per_line_form .hide-button").bind("click", function(){
-      $('.per_line_form').hide();
-      return false;
-    });
-  });

app/views/notes/_per_line_note.html.haml

-%tr.line_notes_row
-  %td{colspan: 3}
-    %ul
-      = render "notes/note", note: note
-

app/views/notes/_per_line_note_link.html.haml

-= link_to "", "#", class: "line_note_link", data: { line_code: line_code }, title: "Add note for this line"

app/views/notes/_per_line_notes_with_reply.html.haml

-- notes.each do |note|
-  = render "notes/per_line_note", note: note
-= render "notes/per_line_reply_button", line_code: notes.first.line_code

app/views/notes/_per_line_reply_button.html.haml

-%tr.line_notes_row.reply
-  %td{colspan: 3}
-    %i.icon-comment
-    = link_to "Reply", "#", class: "line_note_reply_link", data: { line_code: line_code }, title: "Add note for this line"

app/views/notes/_reversed_notes_with_form.html.haml

+.js-main-target-form
 - if can? current_user, :write_note, @project
-  = render "notes/common_form"
+  = render "notes/form"
 
-%ul.reversed#new-notes-list
-%ul.reversed#notes-list
-.notes-status
+%ul#new-notes-list.reversed.notes
+%ul#notes-list.reversed.notes
+.notes-busy.js-notes-busy
 
 :javascript
   $(function(){
-    NoteList.init("#{tid}", "#{tt}", "#{project_notes_path(@project)}");
+    NoteList.init("#{@target_id}", "#{@target_type}", "#{project_notes_path(@project)}");
   });

app/views/notes/create.js.haml

-- if @note.line_code
-  = render "create_per_line_note", note: @note
-- else
-  = render "create_common_note", note: @note
+- if @note.valid?
+  var noteHtml = "#{escape_javascript(render "notes/note", note: @note)}";
+
+  - if note_for_main_target?(@note)
+    - if @note.for_wall?
+      NoteList.appendNewWallNote(#{@note.id}, noteHtml);
+    - else
+      NoteList.appendNewNote(#{@note.id}, noteHtml);
+  - else
+    :plain
+      var firstDiscussionNoteHtml = "#{escape_javascript(render "notes/diff_notes_with_reply", notes: [@note])}";
+      NoteList.appendNewDiscussionNote("#{@note.discussion_id}",
+                                       firstDiscussionNoteHtml,
+                                       noteHtml);
 
--# Enable submit button
-:plain
-  $("#submit_note").removeAttr("disabled");
+- else
+  var errorsHtml = "#{escape_javascript(render 'notes/form_errors', note: @note)}";
+  - if note_for_main_target?(@note)
+    NoteList.errorsOnForm(errorsHtml);
+  - else
+    NoteList.errorsOnForm(errorsHtml, "#{@note.discussion_id}");
\ No newline at end of file

app/views/notes/index.js.haml

 - unless @notes.blank?
+  var notesHtml = "#{escape_javascript(render 'notes/notes')}";
+  - new_note_ids = @notes.map(&:id)
   - if loading_more_notes?
-    :plain
-      NoteList.appendMoreNotes(#{@notes.last.id}, "#{escape_javascript(render 'notes/notes')}");
+    NoteList.appendMoreNotes(#{new_note_ids}, notesHtml);
 
   - elsif loading_new_notes?
-    :plain
-      NoteList.replaceNewNotes("#{escape_javascript(render 'notes/notes')}");
+    NoteList.replaceNewNotes(#{new_note_ids}, notesHtml);
 
   - else
-    :plain
-      NoteList.setContent(#{@notes.first.id}, #{@notes.last.id}, "#{escape_javascript(render 'notes/notes')}");
+    NoteList.setContent(#{new_note_ids}, notesHtml);
 
 - else
   - if loading_more_notes?
-    :plain
     NoteList.finishedLoadingMore();

app/views/projects/wall.html.haml

 %div.wall_page
-  = render "notes/reversed_notes_with_form", tid: nil, tt: "wall"
+  = render "notes/reversed_notes_with_form"

app/views/snippets/show.html.haml

@@ -8,4 +8,4 @@
 
 %br
 %div= render 'blob'
-%div#notes= render "notes/notes_with_form", tid: @snippet.id, tt: "snippet"
+%div#notes= render "notes/notes_with_form"

features/project/commits/commit_comments.feature

-Feature: Project Comment commit
+Feature: Comments on commits
   Background:
     Given I sign in as a user
     And I own project "Shop"
-    Given I visit project commit page
+    And I visit project commit page
 
   @javascript
-  Scenario: I comment commit
+  Scenario: I can comment on a commit
     Given I leave a comment like "XML attached"
-    Then I should see comment "XML attached"
+    Then I should see a comment saying "XML attached"
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can't cancel the main form
+    Then I should not see the cancel comment button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can't preview without text
+    Given I haven't written any comment text
+    Then I should not see the comment preview button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can preview with text
+    Given I write a comment like "Nice"
+    Then I should see the comment preview button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I preview a comment
+    Given I preview a comment text like "Bug fixed :smile:"
+    Then I should see the comment preview
+    And I should not see the comment text field
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can edit after preview
+    Given I preview a comment text like "Bug fixed :smile:"
+    Then I should see the comment edit button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I have a reset form after posting from preview
+    Given I preview a comment text like "Bug fixed :smile:"
+    And I submit the comment
+    Then I should see an empty comment text field
+    And I should not see the comment preview
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can delete a comment
+    Given I leave a comment like "XML attached"
+    And I delete a comment
+    Then I should not see a comment saying "XML attached"

features/project/commits/commit_diff_comments.feature

+Feature: Comments on commit diffs
+  Background:
+    Given I sign in as a user
+    And I own project "Shop"
+    And I visit project commit page
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can access add diff comment buttons
+    Then I should see add a diff comment button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can comment on a commit diff
+    Given I leave a diff comment like "Typo, please fix"
+    Then I should see a diff comment saying "Typo, please fix"
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I get a temporary form for the first comment on a diff line
+    Given I open a diff comment form
+    Then I should see a temporary diff comment form
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I have a cancel button on the diff form
+    Given I open a diff comment form
+    Then I should see the cancel comment button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can cancel a diff form
+    Given I open a diff comment form
+    And I cancel the diff comment
+    Then I should not see the diff comment form
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can't open a second form for a diff line
+    Given I open a diff comment form
+    And I open a diff comment form
+    Then I should only see one diff form
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can have multiple forms
+    Given I open a diff comment form
+    And I write a diff comment like ":-1: I don't like this"
+    And I open another diff comment form
+    Then I should see a diff comment form with ":-1: I don't like this"
+    And I should see an empty diff comment form
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can preview multiple forms separately
+    Given I preview a diff comment text like "Should fix it :smile:"
+    And I preview another diff comment text like "DRY this up"
+    Then I should see two separate previews
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I have a reply button in discussions
+    Given I leave a diff comment like "Typo, please fix"
+    Then I should see a discussion reply button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can't preview without text
+    Given I open a diff comment form
+    And I haven't written any diff comment text
+    Then I should not see the diff comment preview button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can preview with text
+    Given I open a diff comment form
+    And I write a diff comment like ":-1: I don't like this"
+    Then I should see the diff comment preview button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I preview a diff comment
+    Given I preview a diff comment text like "Should fix it :smile:"
+    Then I should see the diff comment preview
+    And I should not see the diff comment text field
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can edit after preview
+    Given I preview a diff comment text like "Should fix it :smile:"
+    Then I should see the diff comment edit button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: The form gets removed after posting
+    Given I preview a diff comment text like "Should fix it :smile:"
+    And I submit the diff comment
+    Then I should not see the diff comment form
+    And I should see a discussion reply button
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I can delete a discussion comment
+    Given I leave a diff comment like "Typo, please fix"
+    And I delete a diff comment
+    Then I should not see a diff comment saying "Typo, please fix"

features/project/merge_requests.feature

@@ -35,8 +35,34 @@ Feature: Project Merge Requests
     Then I should see merge request "Wiki Feature"
 
   @javascript
-  Scenario: I comment merge request
+  Scenario: I comment on a merge request
     Given I visit merge request page "Bug NS-04"
     And I leave a comment like "XML attached"
     Then I should see comment "XML attached"
 
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I comment on a merge request diff
+    Given project "Shop" have "Bug NS-05" open merge request with diffs inside
+    And I visit merge request page "Bug NS-05"
+    And I switch to the diff tab
+    And I leave a comment like "Line is wrong" on line 185 of the first file
+    And I switch to the merge request's comments tab
+    Then I should see a discussion has started on line 185
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I comment on a line of a commit in merge request
+    Given project "Shop" have "Bug NS-05" open merge request with diffs inside
+    And I visit merge request page "Bug NS-05"
+    And I click on the first commit in the merge request
+    And I leave a comment like "Line is wrong" on line 185 of the first file
+    And I switch to the merge request's comments tab
+    Then I should see a discussion has started on commit bcf03b5de6c:L185
+
+  @javascript
+  Scenario: I comment on a commit in merge request
+    Given project "Shop" have "Bug NS-05" open merge request with diffs inside
+    And I visit merge request page "Bug NS-05"
+    And I click on the first commit in the merge request
+    And I leave a comment on the diff page
+    And I switch to the merge request's comments tab
+    Then I should see a discussion has started on commit bcf03b5de6c

features/steps/project/comments_on_commit_diffs.rb

+class CommentsOnCommitDiffs < Spinach::FeatureSteps
+  include SharedAuthentication
+  include SharedDiffNote
+  include SharedPaths
+  include SharedProject
+end

features/steps/project/project_comment_commit.rb → features/steps/project/comments_on_commits.rb

-class ProjectCommentCommit < Spinach::FeatureSteps
+class CommentsOnCommits < Spinach::FeatureSteps
   include SharedAuthentication
-  include SharedProject
   include SharedNote
   include SharedPaths
+  include SharedProject
 end

features/steps/project/project_merge_requests.rb

@@ -4,50 +4,55 @@ class ProjectMergeRequests < Spinach::FeatureSteps
   include SharedNote
   include SharedPaths
 
-  Then 'I should see "Bug NS-04" in merge requests' do
-    page.should have_content "Bug NS-04"
+  Given 'I click link "New Merge Request"' do
+    click_link "New Merge Request"
   end
 
-  And 'I should not see "Feature NS-03" in merge requests' do
-    page.should_not have_content "Feature NS-03"
+  Given 'I click link "Bug NS-04"' do
+    click_link "Bug NS-04"
+  end
+
+  Given 'I click link "All"' do
+    click_link "All"
   end
 
   Given 'I click link "Closed"' do
     click_link "Closed"
   end
 
-  Then 'I should see "Feature NS-03" in merge requests' do
-    page.should have_content "Feature NS-03"
+  Then 'I should see merge request "Wiki Feature"' do
+    page.should have_content "Wiki Feature"
   end
 
-  And 'I should not see "Bug NS-04" in merge requests' do
-    page.should_not have_content "Bug NS-04"
+  Then 'I should see closed merge request "Bug NS-04"' do
+    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-04")
+    mr.closed.should be_true
+    page.should have_content "Closed by"
   end
 
-  Given 'I click link "All"' do
-    click_link "All"
+  Then 'I should see merge request "Bug NS-04"' do
+    page.should have_content "Bug NS-04"
   end
 
-  Given 'I click link "Bug NS-04"' do
-    click_link "Bug NS-04"
+  Then 'I should see "Bug NS-04" in merge requests' do
+    page.should have_content "Bug NS-04"
   end
 
-  Then 'I should see merge request "Bug NS-04"' do
-    page.should have_content "Bug NS-04"
+  Then 'I should see "Feature NS-03" in merge requests' do
+    page.should have_content "Feature NS-03"
   end
 
-  And 'I click link "Close"' do
-    click_link "Close"
+  And 'I should not see "Feature NS-03" in merge requests' do
+    page.should_not have_content "Feature NS-03"
   end
 
-  Then 'I should see closed merge request "Bug NS-04"' do
-    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-04")
-    mr.closed.should be_true
-    page.should have_content "Closed by"
+
+  And 'I should not see "Bug NS-04" in merge requests' do
+    page.should_not have_content "Bug NS-04"
   end
 
-  Given 'I click link "New Merge Request"' do
-    click_link "New Merge Request"
+  And 'I click link "Close"' do
+    click_link "Close"
   end
 
   And 'I submit new merge request "Wiki Feature"' do
@@ -57,24 +62,91 @@ class ProjectMergeRequests < Spinach::FeatureSteps
     click_button "Submit merge request"
   end
 
-  Then 'I should see merge request "Wiki Feature"' do
-    page.should have_content "Wiki Feature"
-  end
-
   And 'project "Shop" have "Bug NS-04" open merge request' do
     project = Project.find_by_name("Shop")
     create(:merge_request,
-           :title => "Bug NS-04",
-           :project => project,
-           :author => project.users.first)
+           title: "Bug NS-04",
+           project: project,
+           author: project.users.first)
+  end
+
+  And 'project "Shop" have "Bug NS-05" open merge request with diffs inside' do
+    project = Project.find_by_name("Shop")
+    create(:merge_request_with_diffs,
+           title: "Bug NS-05",
+           project: project,
+           author: project.users.first)
   end
 
   And 'project "Shop" have "Feature NS-03" closed merge request' do
     project = Project.find_by_name("Shop")
     create(:merge_request,
-           :title => "Feature NS-03",
-           :project => project,
-           :author => project.users.first,
-           :closed => true)
+           title: "Feature NS-03",
+           project: project,
+           author: project.users.first,
+           closed: true)
+  end
+
+  And 'I switch to the diff tab' do
+    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-05")
+    visit diffs_project_merge_request_path(mr.project, mr)
+  end
+
+  And 'I switch to the merge request\'s comments tab' do
+    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-05")
+    visit project_merge_request_path(mr.project, mr)
+  end
+
+  And 'I click on the first commit in the merge request' do
+    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-05")
+    click_link mr.commits.first.short_id(8)
+  end
+
+  And 'I leave a comment on the diff page' do
+    within(:xpath, "//div[@class='note-form-holder']") do
+      fill_in "note_note", with: "One comment to rule them all"
+      click_button "Add Comment"
+    end
+  end
+
+  And 'I leave a comment like "Line is wrong" on line 185 of the first file' do
+    save_and_open_page
+    within(:xpath, "//div[@class='diff_file'][1]") do
+      click_link "add-diff-line-note-0_185_185"
+    end
+
+    within(:xpath, "//div[@class='line-note-form-holder']") do
+      fill_in "note_note", with: "Line is wrong"
+      click_button "Add Comment"
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see a discussion has started on line 185' do
+    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-05")
+    first_commit = mr.commits.first
+    first_diff   = mr.diffs.first
+    page.should have_content "#{current_user.name} started a discussion on this merge request diff"
+    page.should have_content "#{first_diff.b_path}:L185"
+    page.should have_content "Line is wrong"
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see a discussion has started on commit bcf03b5de6c:L185' do
+    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-05")
+    first_commit = mr.commits.first
+    first_diff   = mr.diffs.first
+    page.should have_content "#{current_user.name} started a discussion on commit"
+    page.should have_content first_commit.short_id(8)
+    page.should have_content "#{first_diff.b_path}:L185"
+    page.should have_content "Line is wrong"
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see a discussion has started on commit bcf03b5de6c' do
+    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-05")
+    first_commit = mr.st_commits.first
+    first_diff   = mr.diffs.first
+    page.should have_content "#{current_user.name} started a discussion on commit"
+    page.should have_content first_commit.short_id(8)
+    page.should have_content "One comment to rule them all"
+    page.should_not have_content "#{first_diff.b_path}:L185"
   end
 end

features/steps/shared/diff_note.rb

+module SharedDiffNote
+  include Spinach::DSL
+
+  Given 'I cancel the diff comment' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      find(".js-close-discussion-note-form").trigger("click")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Given 'I delete a diff comment' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      first(".js-note-delete").trigger("click")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Given 'I haven\'t written any diff comment text' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: ""
+    end
+  end
+
+  Given 'I leave a diff comment like "Typo, please fix"' do
+    find("#586fb7c4e1add2d4d24e27566ed7064680098646_29_14.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: "Typo, please fix"
+      #click_button("Add Comment")
+      find(".js-comment-button").trigger("click")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Given 'I preview a diff comment text like "Should fix it :smile:"' do
+    find("#586fb7c4e1add2d4d24e27566ed7064680098646_29_14.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: "Should fix it :smile:"
+      find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Given 'I preview another diff comment text like "DRY this up"' do
+    find("#586fb7c4e1add2d4d24e27566ed7064680098646_57_41.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: "DRY this up"
+      find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Given 'I open a diff comment form' do
+    find("#586fb7c4e1add2d4d24e27566ed7064680098646_29_14.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+  end
+
+  Given 'I open another diff comment form' do
+    find("#586fb7c4e1add2d4d24e27566ed7064680098646_57_41.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+  end
+
+  Given 'I write a diff comment like ":-1: I don\'t like this"' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: ":-1: I don\'t like this"
+    end
+  end
+
+  Given 'I submit the diff comment' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      click_button("Add Comment")
+    end
+  end
+
+
+
+  Then 'I should not see the diff comment form' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should_not have_css("form.new_note")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should not see the diff comment preview button' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: false)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should not see the diff comment text field' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-text", visible: false)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should only see one diff form' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_css("form.new_note", count: 1)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see a diff comment form with ":-1: I don\'t like this"' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_field("note[note]", with: ":-1: I don\'t like this")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see a diff comment saying "Typo, please fix"' do
+    within(".diff_file .note") do
+      page.should have_content("Typo, please fix")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see a discussion reply button' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_link("Reply")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see a temporary diff comment form' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-temp-notes-holder form.new_note")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see add a diff comment button' do
+    page.should have_css(".js-add-diff-note-button", visible: false)
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see an empty diff comment form' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_field("note[note]", with: "")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see the cancel comment button' do
+    within(".diff_file form") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-close-discussion-note-form", text: "Cancel")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see the diff comment preview' do
+    within(".diff_file form") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-preview", visible: false)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see the diff comment edit button' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-edit-button", visible: true)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see the diff comment preview button' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: true)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see two separate previews' do
+    within(".diff_file") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-preview", visible: true, count: 2)
+      page.should have_content("Should fix it")
+      page.should have_content("DRY this up")
+    end
+  end
+end

features/steps/shared/note.rb

 module SharedNote
   include Spinach::DSL
 
+  Given 'I delete a comment' do
+    first(".js-note-delete").trigger("click")
+  end
+
+  Given 'I haven\'t written any comment text' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: ""
+    end
+  end
+
   Given 'I leave a comment like "XML attached"' do
-    fill_in "note_note", :with => "XML attached"
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: "XML attached"
       click_button "Add Comment"
     end
+  end
 
-  Then 'I should see comment "XML attached"' do
-    page.should have_content "XML attached"
+  Given 'I preview a comment text like "Bug fixed :smile:"' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: "Bug fixed :smile:"
+      find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+    end
   end
 
+  Given 'I submit the comment' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      click_button "Add Comment"
+    end
+  end
+
+  Given 'I write a comment like "Nice"' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: "Nice"
+    end
+  end
+
+
+
+  Then 'I should not see a comment saying "XML attached"' do
+    page.should_not have_css(".note")
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should not see the cancel comment button' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      should_not have_link("Cancel")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should not see the comment preview' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-preview", visible: false)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should not see the comment preview button' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: false)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should not see the comment text field' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-text", visible: false)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see a comment saying "XML attached"' do
+    within(".note") do
+      page.should have_content("XML attached")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see an empty comment text field' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      page.should have_field("note[note]", with: "")
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see the comment edit button' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-edit-button", visible: true)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see the comment preview' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-preview", visible: true)
+    end
+  end
+
+  Then 'I should see the comment preview button' do
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      page.should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: true)
+    end
+  end
+
+
+
+  # Wall
+
   Given 'I write new comment "my special test message"' do
-    fill_in "note_note", :with => "my special test message"
+    within(".js-main-target-form") do
+      fill_in "note[note]", with: "my special test message"
       click_button "Add Comment"
     end
+  end
 
   Then 'I should see project wall note "my special test message"' do
     page.should have_content "my special test message"

features/steps/shared/paths.rb

@@ -224,6 +224,11 @@ module SharedPaths
     visit project_merge_request_path(mr.project, mr)
   end
 
+  Given 'I visit merge request page "Bug NS-05"' do
+    mr = MergeRequest.find_by_title("Bug NS-05")
+    visit project_merge_request_path(mr.project, mr)
+  end
+
   And 'I visit project "Shop" merge requests page' do
     visit project_merge_requests_path(Project.find_by_name("Shop"))
   end

lib/gitlab/markdown.rb

@@ -25,22 +25,6 @@ module Gitlab
   #   >> gfm(":trollface:")
   #   => "<img alt=\":trollface:\" class=\"emoji\" src=\"/images/trollface.png" title=\":trollface:\" />
   module Markdown
-    REFERENCE_PATTERN = %r{
-      (?<prefix>\W)?                         # Prefix
-      (                                      # Reference
-         @(?<user>[a-zA-Z][a-zA-Z0-9_\-\.]*) # User name
-        |\#(?<issue>\d+)                     # Issue ID
-        |!(?<merge_request>\d+)              # MR ID
-        |\$(?<snippet>\d+)                   # Snippet ID
-        |(?<commit>[\h]{6,40})               # Commit ID
-      )
-      (?<suffix>\W)?                         # Suffix
-    }x.freeze
-
-    TYPES = [:user, :issue, :merge_request, :snippet, :commit].freeze
-
-    EMOJI_PATTERN = %r{(:(\S+):)}.freeze
-
     attr_reader :html_options
 
     # Public: Parse the provided text with GitLab-Flavored Markdown
@@ -96,6 +80,20 @@ module Gitlab
       text
     end
 
+    REFERENCE_PATTERN = %r{
+      (?<prefix>\W)?                         # Prefix
+      (                                      # Reference
+         @(?<user>[a-zA-Z][a-zA-Z0-9_\-\.]*) # User name
+        |\#(?<issue>\d+)                     # Issue ID
+        |!(?<merge_request>\d+)              # MR ID
+        |\$(?<snippet>\d+)                   # Snippet ID
+        |(?<commit>[\h]{6,40})               # Commit ID
+      )
+      (?<suffix>\W)?                         # Suffix
+    }x.freeze
+
+    TYPES = [:user, :issue, :merge_request, :snippet, :commit].freeze
+
     def parse_references(text)
       # parse reference links
       text.gsub!(REFERENCE_PATTERN) do |match|
@@ -115,11 +113,13 @@ module Gitlab
       end
     end
 
+    EMOJI_PATTERN = %r{(:(\S+):)}.freeze
+
     def parse_emoji(text)
       # parse emoji
       text.gsub!(EMOJI_PATTERN) do |match|
         if valid_emoji?($2)
-          image_tag("emoji/#{$2}.png", size: "20x20", class: 'emoji', title: $1, alt: $1)
+          image_tag("emoji/#{$2}.png", class: 'emoji', title: $1, alt: $1, size: "20x20")
         else
           match
         end

spec/factories.rb

@@ -73,8 +73,8 @@ FactoryGirl.define do
 
     # pick 3 commits "at random" (from bcf03b5d~3 to bcf03b5d)
     trait :with_diffs do
-      target_branch "bcf03b5d~3"
-      source_branch "bcf03b5d"
+      target_branch "master" # pretend bcf03b5d~3
+      source_branch "stable" # pretend bcf03b5d
       st_commits do
         [Commit.new(project.repo.commit('bcf03b5d')),
          Commit.new(project.repo.commit('bcf03b5d~1')),
@@ -92,6 +92,32 @@ FactoryGirl.define do
   factory :note do
     project
     note "Note"
+    author
+
+    factory :note_on_commit, traits: [:on_commit]
+    factory :note_on_commit_diff, traits: [:on_commit, :on_diff]
+    factory :note_on_issue, traits: [:on_issue], aliases: [:votable_note]
+    factory :note_on_merge_request, traits: [:on_merge_request]
+    factory :note_on_merge_request_diff, traits: [:on_merge_request, :on_diff]
+
+    trait :on_commit do
+      commit_id     "bcf03b5de6c33f3869ef70d68cf06e679d1d7f9a"
+      noteable_type "Commit"
+    end
+
+    trait :on_diff do
+      line_code "0_184_184"
+    end
+
+    trait :on_merge_request do
+      noteable_id   1
+      noteable_type "MergeRequest"
+    end
+
+    trait :on_issue do
+      noteable_id   1
+      noteable_type "Issue"
+    end
   end
 
   factory :event do

spec/lib/votes_spec.rb

 require 'spec_helper'
 
 describe Issue do
-  let(:issue) { create(:issue) }
+  it { should include_module(Votes) }
+end
+
+describe MergeRequest do
+  let(:merge_request) { FactoryGirl.create(:merge_request_with_diffs) }
+
+  it { should include_module(Votes) }
 
   describe "#upvotes" do
     it "with no notes has a 0/0 score" do
-      issue.upvotes.should == 0
+      merge_request.upvotes.should == 0
     end
 
     it "should recognize non-+1 notes" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "No +1 here")
-      issue.should have(1).note
-      issue.notes.first.upvote?.should be_false
-      issue.upvotes.should == 0
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "No +1 here")
+      merge_request.should have(1).note
+      merge_request.notes.first.upvote?.should be_false
+      merge_request.upvotes.should == 0
     end
 
     it "should recognize a single +1 note" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
-      issue.upvotes.should == 1
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
+      merge_request.upvotes.should == 1
     end
 
     it "should recognize multiple +1 notes" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
-      issue.upvotes.should == 2
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
+      merge_request.upvotes.should == 2
     end
   end
 
   describe "#downvotes" do
     it "with no notes has a 0/0 score" do
-      issue.downvotes.should == 0
+      merge_request.downvotes.should == 0
     end
 
     it "should recognize non--1 notes" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "Almost got a -1")
-      issue.should have(1).note
-      issue.notes.first.downvote?.should be_false
-      issue.downvotes.should == 0
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "Almost got a -1")
+      merge_request.should have(1).note
+      merge_request.notes.first.downvote?.should be_false
+      merge_request.downvotes.should == 0
     end
 
     it "should recognize a single -1 note" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
-      issue.downvotes.should == 1
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
+      merge_request.downvotes.should == 1
     end
 
     it "should recognize multiple -1 notes" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 Away with this")
-      issue.downvotes.should == 2
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 Away with this")
+      merge_request.downvotes.should == 2
     end
   end
 
   describe "#votes_count" do
     it "with no notes has a 0/0 score" do
-      issue.votes_count.should == 0
+      merge_request.votes_count.should == 0
     end
 
     it "should recognize non notes" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "No +1 here")
-      issue.should have(1).note
-      issue.votes_count.should == 0
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "No +1 here")
+      merge_request.should have(1).note
+      merge_request.votes_count.should == 0
     end
 
     it "should recognize a single +1 note" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
-      issue.votes_count.should == 1
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
+      merge_request.votes_count.should == 1
     end
 
     it "should recognize a single -1 note" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
-      issue.votes_count.should == 1
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
+      merge_request.votes_count.should == 1
     end
 
     it "should recognize multiple notes" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
-      issue.votes_count.should == 3
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
+      merge_request.votes_count.should == 3
     end
   end
 
   describe "#upvotes_in_percent" do
     it "with no notes has a 0% score" do
-      issue.upvotes_in_percent.should == 0
+      merge_request.upvotes_in_percent.should == 0
     end
 
     it "should count a single 1 note as 100%" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
-      issue.upvotes_in_percent.should == 100
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
+      merge_request.upvotes_in_percent.should == 100
     end
 
     it "should count multiple +1 notes as 100%" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
-      issue.upvotes_in_percent.should == 100
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
+      merge_request.upvotes_in_percent.should == 100
     end
 
     it "should count fractions for multiple +1 and -1 notes correctly" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 me too")
-      issue.upvotes_in_percent.should == 75
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 me too")
+      merge_request.upvotes_in_percent.should == 75
     end
   end
 
   describe "#downvotes_in_percent" do
     it "with no notes has a 0% score" do
-      issue.downvotes_in_percent.should == 0
+      merge_request.downvotes_in_percent.should == 0
     end
 
     it "should count a single -1 note as 100%" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
-      issue.downvotes_in_percent.should == 100
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
+      merge_request.downvotes_in_percent.should == 100
     end
 
     it "should count multiple -1 notes as 100%" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 Away with this")
-      issue.downvotes_in_percent.should == 100
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 Away with this")
+      merge_request.downvotes_in_percent.should == 100
     end
 
     it "should count fractions for multiple +1 and -1 notes correctly" do
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
-      issue.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 me too")
-      issue.downvotes_in_percent.should == 25
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 This is awesome")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 I want this")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "-1 This is bad")
+      merge_request.notes << create(:note, note: "+1 me too")
+      merge_request.downvotes_in_percent.should == 25
     end
   end
 end

spec/models/note_spec.rb

@@ -38,34 +38,34 @@ describe Note do
     let(:project) { create(:project) }
 
     it "recognizes a neutral note" do
-      note = create(:note, note: "This is not a +1 note")
+      note = create(:votable_note, note: "This is not a +1 note")
       note.should_not be_upvote
       note.should_not be_downvote
     end
 
     it "recognizes a neutral emoji note" do
-      note = build(:note, note: "I would :+1: this, but I don't want to")
+      note = build(:votable_note, note: "I would :+1: this, but I don't want to")
       note.should_not be_upvote
       note.should_not be_downvote
     end
 
     it "recognizes a +1 note" do
-      note = create(:note, note: "+1 for this")
+      note = create(:votable_note, note: "+1 for this")
       note.should be_upvote
     end
 
     it "recognizes a +1 emoji as a vote" do
-      note = build(:note, note: ":+1: for this")
+      note = build(:votable_note, note: ":+1: for this")
       note.should be_upvote
     end
 
     it "recognizes a -1 note" do
-      note = create(:note, note: "-1 for this")
+      note = create(:votable_note, note: "-1 for this")
       note.should be_downvote
     end
 
     it "recognizes a -1 emoji as a vote" do
-      note = build(:note, note: ":-1: for this")
+      note = build(:votable_note, note: ":-1: for this")
       note.should be_downvote
     end
   end
@@ -74,43 +74,72 @@ describe Note do
   let(:commit) { project.repository.commit }
 
   describe "Commit notes" do
-    before do
-      @note = create(:note,
-                     commit_id: commit.id,
-                     noteable_type: "Commit")
-    end
+    let!(:note) { create(:note_on_commit, note: "+1 from me") }
+    let!(:commit) { note.noteable }
 
     it "should be accessible through #noteable" do
-      @note.commit_id.should == commit.id
-      @note.noteable.should be_a(Commit)
-      @note.noteable.should == commit
+      note.commit_id.should == commit.id
+      note.noteable.should be_a(Commit)
+      note.noteable.should == commit
     end
 
     it "should save a valid note" do
-      @note.commit_id.should == commit.id
-      @note.noteable == commit
+      note.commit_id.should == commit.id
+      note.noteable == commit
     end
 
     it "should be recognized by #for_commit?" do
-      @note.should be_for_commit
-    end
+      note.should be_for_commit
     end
 
-  describe "Pre-line commit notes" do
-    before do
-      @note = create(:note,
-                     commit_id: commit.id,
-                     noteable_type: "Commit",
-                     line_code: "0_16_1")
+    it "should not be votable" do
+      note.should_not be_votable
+    end
   end
 
+  describe "Commit diff line notes" do
+    let!(:note) { create(:note_on_commit_line, note: "+1 from me") }
+    let!(:commit) { note.noteable }
+
     it "should save a valid note" do
-      @note.commit_id.should == commit.id
-      @note.noteable.id.should == commit.id
+      note.commit_id.should == commit.id
+      note.noteable.id.should == commit.id
     end
 
     it "should be recognized by #for_diff_line?" do
-      @note.should be_for_diff_line
+      note.should be_for_diff_line
+    end
+
+    it "should be recognized by #for_commit_diff_line?" do
+      note.should be_for_commit_diff_line
+    end
+
+    it "should not be votable" do
+      note.should_not be_votable
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "Issue notes" do
+    let!(:note) { create(:note_on_issue, note: "+1 from me") }
+
+    it "should not be votable" do
+      note.should be_votable
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "Merge request notes" do
+    let!(:note) { create(:note_on_merge_request, note: "+1 from me") }
+
+    it "should not be votable" do
+      note.should be_votable
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "Merge request diff line notes" do
+    let!(:note) { create(:note_on_merge_request_line, note: "+1 from me") }
+
+    it "should not be votable" do
+      note.should_not be_votable
     end
   end
 

spec/requests/notes_on_merge_requests_spec.rb

+require 'spec_helper'
+
+describe "On a merge request", js: true do
+  let!(:project) { create(:project) }
+  let!(:merge_request) { create(:merge_request, project: project) }
+
+  before do
+    login_as :user
+    project.team << [@user, :master]
+
+    visit project_merge_request_path(project, merge_request)
+  end
+
+  subject { page }
+
+  describe "the note form" do
+    # main target form creation
+    it { should have_css(".js-main-target-form", visible: true, count: 1) }
+
+    # button initalization
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_button("Add Comment") } }
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should_not have_link("Cancel") } }
+
+    # notifiactions
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_checked_field("Project team") } }
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should_not have_checked_field("Commit author") } }
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should_not have_unchecked_field("Commit author") } }
+
+    describe "without text" do
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: false) } }
+    end
+
+    describe "with text" do
+      before do
+        within(".js-main-target-form") do
+          fill_in "note[note]", with: "This is awesome"
+        end
+      end
+
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should_not have_css(".js-comment-button[disabled]") } }
+
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: true) } }
+    end
+
+    describe "with preview" do
+      before do
+        within(".js-main-target-form") do
+          fill_in "note[note]", with: "This is awesome"
+          find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+        end
+      end
+
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview", text: "This is awesome", visible: true) } }
+
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: false) } }
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-edit-button", visible: true) } }
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "when posting a note" do
+    before do
+      within(".js-main-target-form") do
+        fill_in "note[note]", with: "This is awsome!"
+        find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+        click_button "Add Comment"
+      end
+    end
+
+    # note added
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_content("This is awsome!") } }
+
+    # reset form
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_no_field("note[note]", with: "This is awesome!")  } }
+
+    # return from preview
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview", visible: false) } }
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-text", visible: true) } }
+
+
+    it "should be removable" do
+      find(".js-note-delete").trigger("click")
+
+      should_not have_css(".note")
+    end
+  end
+end
+
+
+
+describe "On a merge request diff", js: true, focus: true do
+  let!(:project) { create(:project) }
+  let!(:merge_request) { create(:merge_request_with_diffs, project: project) }
+
+  before do
+    login_as :user
+    project.team << [@user, :master]
+
+    visit diffs_project_merge_request_path(project, merge_request)
+
+    click_link("Diff")
+  end
+
+  subject { page }
+
+  describe "when adding a note" do
+    before do
+      find("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_185_185.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+    end
+
+    describe "the notes holder" do
+      it { should have_css("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_185_185.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder") }
+
+      it { within(".js-temp-notes-holder") { should have_css(".new_note") } }
+    end
+
+    describe "the note form" do
+      # set up hidden fields correctly
+      it { within(".js-temp-notes-holder") { find("#note_noteable_type").value.should == "MergeRequest" } }
+      it { within(".js-temp-notes-holder") { find("#note_noteable_id").value.should == "" } }
+      it { within(".js-temp-notes-holder") { find("#note_commit_id").value.should == "bcf03b5de6c33f3869ef70d68cf06e679d1d7f9a" } }
+      it { within(".js-temp-notes-holder") { find("#note_line_code").value.should == "4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_185_185" } }
+
+      # buttons
+      it { should have_button("Add Comment") }
+      it { should have_css(".js-close-discussion-note-form", text: "Cancel") }
+
+      # notification options
+      it { should have_unchecked_field("Project team") }
+      it { should have_checked_field("Commit author") }
+
+      it "shouldn't add a second form for same row" do
+        find("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_185_185.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+
+        should have_css("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_185_185.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder form", count: 1)
+      end
+
+      it "should be removed when canceled" do
+        find(".js-close-discussion-note-form").trigger("click")
+
+        should have_no_css(".js-temp-notes-holder")
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "with muliple note forms" do
+    before do
+      find("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_185_185.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+      find("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+    end
+
+    # has two line forms
+    it { should have_css(".js-temp-notes-holder", count: 2) }
+
+    describe "previewing them separately" do
+      before do
+        # add two separate texts and trigger previews on both
+        within("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_185_185.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder") do
+          fill_in "note[note]", with: "One comment on line 185"
+          find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+        end
+        within("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder") do
+          fill_in "note[note]", with: "Another comment on line 17"
+          find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+        end
+      end
+
+      # check if previews were rendered separately
+      it { within("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_185_185.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder") { should have_css(".js-note-preview", text: "One comment on line 185") } }
+      it { within("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder") { should have_css(".js-note-preview", text: "Another comment on line 17") } }
+    end
+
+    describe "posting a note" do
+      before do
+        within("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder") do
+          fill_in "note[note]", with: "Another comment on line 17"
+          click_button("Add Comment")
+        end
+      end
+
+      # removed form after submit
+      it { should have_no_css("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder") }
+
+      # added discussion
+      it { should have_content("Another comment on line 17") }
+      it { should have_css("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder + .notes_holder") }
+      it { should have_css("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder + .notes_holder .note", count: 1) }
+      it { should have_link("Reply") }
+
+      it "should remove last note of a discussion" do
+        within("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder + .notes_holder") do
+          find(".js-note-delete").trigger("click")
+        end
+
+        # removed whole discussion
+        should_not have_css(".note_holder")
+        should have_css("#342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_17.line_holder + #342e16cbbd482ac2047dc679b2749d248cc1428f_18_18.line_holder")
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "when replying to a note" do
+    before do
+      # create first note
+      find("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_184_184.line_holder .js-add-diff-note-button").trigger("click")
+      within("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_184_184.line_holder + .js-temp-notes-holder") do
+        fill_in "note[note]", with: "One comment on line 184"
+        click_button("Add Comment")
+      end
+      # create second note
+      within("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_184_184.line_holder + .notes_holder") do
+        find(".js-discussion-reply-button").trigger("click")
+        fill_in "note[note]", with: "An additional comment in reply"
+        click_button("Add Comment")
+      end
+    end
+
+    # inserted note
+    it { should have_content("An additional comment in reply") }
+    it { within("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_184_184.line_holder + .notes_holder") { should have_css(".note", count: 2) } }
+
+    # removed form after reply
+    it { within("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_184_184.line_holder + .notes_holder") { should have_no_css("form") } }
+    it { within("#4735dfc552ad7bf15ca468adc3cad9d05b624490_184_184.line_holder + .notes_holder") { should have_link("Reply") } }
+  end
+end
+
+
+
+describe "On merge request discussion", js: true do
+  describe "with merge request diff note"
+  describe "with commit note"
+  describe "with commit diff note"
+end

spec/requests/notes_on_wall_spec.rb

+require 'spec_helper'
+
+describe "On the project wall", js: true do
+  let!(:project) { create(:project) }
+  let!(:commit) { project.commit("bcf03b5de6c33f3869ef70d68cf06e679d1d7f9a") }
+
+  before do
+    login_as :user
+    project.team << [@user, :master]
+    visit wall_project_path(project)
+  end
+
+  subject { page }
+
+  describe "the note form" do
+    # main target form creation
+    it { should have_css(".js-main-target-form", visible: true, count: 1) }
+
+    # button initalization
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_button("Add Comment") } }
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should_not have_link("Cancel") } }
+
+    # notifiactions
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_checked_field("Project team") } }
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should_not have_checked_field("Commit author") } }
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should_not have_unchecked_field("Commit author") } }
+
+    describe "without text" do
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: false) } }
+    end
+
+    describe "with text" do
+      before do
+        within(".js-main-target-form") do
+          fill_in "note[note]", with: "This is awesome"
+        end
+      end
+
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should_not have_css(".js-comment-button[disabled]") } }
+
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: true) } }
+    end
+
+    describe "with preview" do
+      before do
+        within(".js-main-target-form") do
+          fill_in "note[note]", with: "This is awesome"
+          find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+        end
+      end
+
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview", text: "This is awesome", visible: true) } }
+
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview-button", visible: false) } }
+      it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-edit-button", visible: true) } }
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "when posting a note" do
+    before do
+      within(".js-main-target-form") do
+        fill_in "note[note]", with: "This is awsome!"
+        find(".js-note-preview-button").trigger("click")
+        click_button "Add Comment"
+      end
+    end
+
+    # note added
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_content("This is awsome!") } }
+
+    # reset form
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_no_field("note[note]", with: "This is awesome!") } }
+
+    # return from preview
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-preview", visible: false) } }
+    it { within(".js-main-target-form") { should have_css(".js-note-text", visible: true) } }
+
+
+    it "should be removable" do
+      find(".js-note-delete").trigger("click")
+
+      should_not have_css(".note")
+    end
+  end
+end