Merge branch '36829-gpg-commit-not-verified-if-signed-with-a-subkey' into 'master'

Add support for GPG subkeys in signature verification

Closes #36829

See merge request gitlab-org/gitlab-ce!14517

app/assets/stylesheets/pages/profile.scss

@@ -108,6 +108,15 @@
   }
 }
 
+.subkeys-list {
+  @include basic-list;
+
+  li {
+    padding: 3px 0;
+    border: none;
+  }
+}
+
 .key-list-item {
   .key-list-item-info {
     @media (min-width: $screen-sm-min) {

app/controllers/profiles/gpg_keys_controller.rb

@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@ class Profiles::GpgKeysController < Profiles::ApplicationController
   before_action :set_gpg_key, only: [:destroy, :revoke]
 
   def index
-    @gpg_keys = current_user.gpg_keys
+    @gpg_keys = current_user.gpg_keys.with_subkeys
     @gpg_key = GpgKey.new
   end
 

app/models/gpg_key.rb

@@ -9,6 +9,9 @@ class GpgKey < ActiveRecord::Base
 
   belongs_to :user
   has_many :gpg_signatures
+  has_many :subkeys, class_name: 'GpgKeySubkey'
+
+  scope :with_subkeys, -> { includes(:subkeys) }
 
   validates :user, presence: true
 
@@ -36,10 +39,12 @@ class GpgKey < ActiveRecord::Base
 
   before_validation :extract_fingerprint, :extract_primary_keyid
   after_commit :update_invalid_gpg_signatures, on: :create
+  after_create :generate_subkeys
 
   def primary_keyid
     super&.upcase
   end
+  alias_method :keyid, :primary_keyid
 
   def fingerprint
     super&.upcase
@@ -49,6 +54,10 @@ class GpgKey < ActiveRecord::Base
     super(value&.strip)
   end
 
+  def keyids
+    [keyid].concat(subkeys.map(&:keyid))
+  end
+
   def user_infos
     @user_infos ||= Gitlab::Gpg.user_infos_from_key(key)
   end
@@ -82,10 +91,11 @@ class GpgKey < ActiveRecord::Base
 
   def revoke
     GpgSignature
-      .where(gpg_key: self)
+      .with_key_and_subkeys(self)
       .where.not(verification_status: GpgSignature.verification_statuses[:unknown_key])
       .update_all(
         gpg_key_id: nil,
+        gpg_key_subkey_id: nil,
         verification_status: GpgSignature.verification_statuses[:unknown_key],
         updated_at: Time.zone.now
       )
@@ -106,4 +116,12 @@ class GpgKey < ActiveRecord::Base
     # only allows one key
     self.primary_keyid = Gitlab::Gpg.primary_keyids_from_key(key).first
   end
+
+  def generate_subkeys
+    gpg_subkeys = Gitlab::Gpg.subkeys_from_key(key)
+
+    gpg_subkeys[primary_keyid]&.each do |subkey_data|
+      subkeys.create!(keyid: subkey_data[:keyid], fingerprint: subkey_data[:fingerprint])
+    end
+  end
 end

app/models/gpg_key_subkey.rb

+class GpgKeySubkey < ActiveRecord::Base
+  include ShaAttribute
+
+  sha_attribute :keyid
+  sha_attribute :fingerprint
+
+  belongs_to :gpg_key
+
+  validates :gpg_key_id, presence: true
+  validates :fingerprint, :keyid, presence: true, uniqueness: true
+
+  delegate :key, :user, :user_infos, :verified?, :verified_user_infos,
+    :verified_and_belongs_to_email?, to: :gpg_key
+
+  def keyid
+    super&.upcase
+  end
+
+  def fingerprint
+    super&.upcase
+  end
+end

app/models/gpg_signature.rb

@@ -15,11 +15,42 @@ class GpgSignature < ActiveRecord::Base
 
   belongs_to :project
   belongs_to :gpg_key
+  belongs_to :gpg_key_subkey
 
   validates :commit_sha, presence: true
   validates :project_id, presence: true
   validates :gpg_key_primary_keyid, presence: true
 
+  def self.with_key_and_subkeys(gpg_key)
+    subkey_ids = gpg_key.subkeys.pluck(:id)
+
+    where(
+      arel_table[:gpg_key_id].eq(gpg_key.id).or(
+        arel_table[:gpg_key_subkey_id].in(subkey_ids)
+      )
+    )
+  end
+
+  def gpg_key=(model)
+    case model
+    when GpgKey
+      super
+    when GpgKeySubkey
+      self.gpg_key_subkey = model
+    when NilClass
+      super
+      self.gpg_key_subkey = nil
+    end
+  end
+
+  def gpg_key
+    if gpg_key_id
+      super
+    elsif gpg_key_subkey_id
+      gpg_key_subkey
+    end
+  end
+
   def gpg_key_primary_keyid
     super&.upcase
   end

app/views/profiles/gpg_keys/_key.html.haml

@@ -7,6 +7,13 @@
 
     .description
       %code= key.fingerprint
+    - if key.subkeys.present?
+      .subkeys
+        %span.bold Subkeys:
+        %ul.subkeys-list
+          - key.subkeys.each do |subkey|
+            %li
+              %code= subkey.fingerprint
   .pull-right
     %span.key-created-at
       created #{time_ago_with_tooltip(key.created_at)}

changelogs/unreleased/36829-add-ability-to-verify-gpg-subkeys.yml

+---
+title: Add support for GPG subkeys in signature verification
+merge_request: 14517
+author:
+type: added

db/migrate/20170927161718_create_gpg_key_subkeys.rb

+class CreateGpgKeySubkeys < ActiveRecord::Migration
+  DOWNTIME = false
+
+  def up
+    create_table :gpg_key_subkeys do |t|
+      t.references :gpg_key, null: false, index: true, foreign_key: { on_delete: :cascade }
+
+      t.binary :keyid
+      t.binary :fingerprint
+
+      t.index :keyid, unique: true, length: Gitlab::Database.mysql? ? 20 : nil
+      t.index :fingerprint, unique: true, length: Gitlab::Database.mysql? ? 20 : nil
+    end
+
+    add_reference :gpg_signatures, :gpg_key_subkey, index: true, foreign_key: { on_delete: :nullify }
+  end
+
+  def down
+    remove_reference(:gpg_signatures, :gpg_key_subkey, index: true, foreign_key: true)
+
+    drop_table :gpg_key_subkeys
+  end
+end

db/post_migrate/20171005130944_schedule_create_gpg_key_subkeys_from_gpg_keys.rb

+# See http://doc.gitlab.com/ce/development/migration_style_guide.html
+# for more information on how to write migrations for GitLab.
+
+class ScheduleCreateGpgKeySubkeysFromGpgKeys < ActiveRecord::Migration
+  disable_ddl_transaction!
+
+  DOWNTIME = false
+  MIGRATION = 'CreateGpgKeySubkeysFromGpgKeys'
+
+  class GpgKey < ActiveRecord::Base
+    self.table_name = 'gpg_keys'
+
+    include EachBatch
+  end
+
+  def up
+    GpgKey.select(:id).each_batch do |gpg_keys|
+      jobs = gpg_keys.pluck(:id).map do |id|
+        [MIGRATION, [id]]
+      end
+
+      BackgroundMigrationWorker.perform_bulk(jobs)
+    end
+  end
+
+  def down
+  end
+end

db/schema.rb

@@ -11,7 +11,7 @@
 #
 # It's strongly recommended that you check this file into your version control system.
 
-ActiveRecord::Schema.define(version: 20171004121444) do
+ActiveRecord::Schema.define(version: 20171005130944) do
 
   # These are extensions that must be enabled in order to support this database
   enable_extension "plpgsql"
@@ -580,6 +580,16 @@ ActiveRecord::Schema.define(version: 20171004121444) do
 
   add_index "forked_project_links", ["forked_to_project_id"], name: "index_forked_project_links_on_forked_to_project_id", unique: true, using: :btree
 
+  create_table "gpg_key_subkeys", force: :cascade do |t|
+    t.integer "gpg_key_id", null: false
+    t.binary "keyid"
+    t.binary "fingerprint"
+  end
+
+  add_index "gpg_key_subkeys", ["fingerprint"], name: "index_gpg_key_subkeys_on_fingerprint", unique: true, using: :btree
+  add_index "gpg_key_subkeys", ["gpg_key_id"], name: "index_gpg_key_subkeys_on_gpg_key_id", using: :btree
+  add_index "gpg_key_subkeys", ["keyid"], name: "index_gpg_key_subkeys_on_keyid", unique: true, using: :btree
+
   create_table "gpg_keys", force: :cascade do |t|
     t.datetime_with_timezone "created_at", null: false
     t.datetime_with_timezone "updated_at", null: false
@@ -603,11 +613,13 @@ ActiveRecord::Schema.define(version: 20171004121444) do
     t.text "gpg_key_user_name"
     t.text "gpg_key_user_email"
     t.integer "verification_status", limit: 2, default: 0, null: false
+    t.integer "gpg_key_subkey_id"
   end
 
   add_index "gpg_signatures", ["commit_sha"], name: "index_gpg_signatures_on_commit_sha", unique: true, using: :btree
   add_index "gpg_signatures", ["gpg_key_id"], name: "index_gpg_signatures_on_gpg_key_id", using: :btree
   add_index "gpg_signatures", ["gpg_key_primary_keyid"], name: "index_gpg_signatures_on_gpg_key_primary_keyid", using: :btree
+  add_index "gpg_signatures", ["gpg_key_subkey_id"], name: "index_gpg_signatures_on_gpg_key_subkey_id", using: :btree
   add_index "gpg_signatures", ["project_id"], name: "index_gpg_signatures_on_project_id", using: :btree
 
   create_table "identities", force: :cascade do |t|
@@ -1727,7 +1739,9 @@ ActiveRecord::Schema.define(version: 20171004121444) do
   add_foreign_key "events", "projects", on_delete: :cascade
   add_foreign_key "events", "users", column: "author_id", name: "fk_edfd187b6f", on_delete: :cascade
   add_foreign_key "forked_project_links", "projects", column: "forked_to_project_id", name: "fk_434510edb0", on_delete: :cascade
+  add_foreign_key "gpg_key_subkeys", "gpg_keys", on_delete: :cascade
   add_foreign_key "gpg_keys", "users", on_delete: :cascade
+  add_foreign_key "gpg_signatures", "gpg_key_subkeys", on_delete: :nullify
   add_foreign_key "gpg_signatures", "gpg_keys", on_delete: :nullify
   add_foreign_key "gpg_signatures", "projects", on_delete: :cascade
   add_foreign_key "issue_assignees", "issues", name: "fk_b7d881734a", on_delete: :cascade

lib/gitlab/background_migration/create_gpg_key_subkeys_from_gpg_keys.rb

+class Gitlab::BackgroundMigration::CreateGpgKeySubkeysFromGpgKeys
+  class GpgKey < ActiveRecord::Base
+    self.table_name = 'gpg_keys'
+
+    include EachBatch
+    include ShaAttribute
+
+    sha_attribute :primary_keyid
+    sha_attribute :fingerprint
+
+    has_many :subkeys, class_name: 'GpgKeySubkey'
+  end
+
+  class GpgKeySubkey < ActiveRecord::Base
+    self.table_name = 'gpg_key_subkeys'
+
+    include ShaAttribute
+
+    sha_attribute :keyid
+    sha_attribute :fingerprint
+  end
+
+  def perform(gpg_key_id)
+    gpg_key = GpgKey.find_by(id: gpg_key_id)
+
+    return if gpg_key.nil?
+    return if gpg_key.subkeys.any?
+
+    create_subkeys(gpg_key)
+    update_signatures(gpg_key)
+  end
+
+  private
+
+  def create_subkeys(gpg_key)
+    gpg_subkeys = Gitlab::Gpg.subkeys_from_key(gpg_key.key)
+
+    gpg_subkeys[gpg_key.primary_keyid.upcase]&.each do |subkey_data|
+      gpg_key.subkeys.build(keyid: subkey_data[:keyid], fingerprint: subkey_data[:fingerprint])
+    end
+
+    # Improve latency by doing all INSERTs in a single call
+    GpgKey.transaction do
+      gpg_key.save!
+    end
+  end
+
+  def update_signatures(gpg_key)
+    return unless gpg_key.subkeys.exists?
+
+    InvalidGpgSignatureUpdateWorker.perform_async(gpg_key.id)
+  end
+end

lib/gitlab/gpg.rb

@@ -34,6 +34,21 @@ module Gitlab
       end
     end
 
+    def subkeys_from_key(key)
+      using_tmp_keychain do
+        fingerprints = CurrentKeyChain.fingerprints_from_key(key)
+        raw_keys     = GPGME::Key.find(:public, fingerprints)
+
+        raw_keys.each_with_object({}) do |raw_key, grouped_subkeys|
+          primary_subkey_id = raw_key.primary_subkey.keyid
+
+          grouped_subkeys[primary_subkey_id] = raw_key.subkeys[1..-1].map do |s|
+            { keyid: s.keyid, fingerprint: s.fingerprint }
+          end
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
     def user_infos_from_key(key)
       using_tmp_keychain do
         fingerprints = CurrentKeyChain.fingerprints_from_key(key)

lib/gitlab/gpg/commit.rb

@@ -43,7 +43,9 @@ module Gitlab
           # key belonging to the keyid.
           # This way we can add the key to the temporary keychain and extract
           # the proper signature.
-          gpg_key = GpgKey.find_by(primary_keyid: verified_signature.fingerprint)
+          # NOTE: the invoked method is #fingerprint but it's only returning
+          # 16 characters (the format used by keyid) instead of 40.
+          gpg_key = find_gpg_key(verified_signature.fingerprint)
 
           if gpg_key
             Gitlab::Gpg::CurrentKeyChain.add(gpg_key.key)
@@ -74,7 +76,7 @@ module Gitlab
           commit_sha: @commit.sha,
           project: @commit.project,
           gpg_key: gpg_key,
-          gpg_key_primary_keyid: gpg_key&.primary_keyid || verified_signature.fingerprint,
+          gpg_key_primary_keyid: gpg_key&.keyid || verified_signature.fingerprint,
           gpg_key_user_name: user_infos[:name],
           gpg_key_user_email: user_infos[:email],
           verification_status: verification_status
@@ -98,6 +100,10 @@ module Gitlab
       def user_infos(gpg_key)
         gpg_key&.verified_user_infos&.first || gpg_key&.user_infos&.first || {}
       end
+
+      def find_gpg_key(keyid)
+        GpgKey.find_by(primary_keyid: keyid) || GpgKeySubkey.find_by(keyid: keyid)
+      end
     end
   end
 end

lib/gitlab/gpg/invalid_gpg_signature_updater.rb

@@ -9,7 +9,7 @@ module Gitlab
         GpgSignature
           .select(:id, :commit_sha, :project_id)
           .where('gpg_key_id IS NULL OR verification_status <> ?', GpgSignature.verification_statuses[:verified])
-          .where(gpg_key_primary_keyid: @gpg_key.primary_keyid)
+          .where(gpg_key_primary_keyid: @gpg_key.keyids)
           .find_each { |sig| sig.gpg_commit.update_signature!(sig) }
       end
     end

spec/factories/gpg_key_subkeys.rb

+require_relative '../support/gpg_helpers'
+
+FactoryGirl.define do
+  factory :gpg_key_subkey do
+    gpg_key
+
+    sequence(:keyid) { |n| "keyid-#{n}" }
+    sequence(:fingerprint) { |n| "fingerprint-#{n}" }
+  end
+end

spec/factories/gpg_keys.rb

@@ -4,5 +4,9 @@ FactoryGirl.define do
   factory :gpg_key do
     key GpgHelpers::User1.public_key
     user
+
+    factory :gpg_key_with_subkeys do
+      key GpgHelpers::User1.public_key_with_extra_signing_key
+    end
   end
 end

spec/factories/gpg_signature.rb

@@ -5,7 +5,7 @@ FactoryGirl.define do
     commit_sha { Digest::SHA1.hexdigest(SecureRandom.hex) }
     project
     gpg_key
-    gpg_key_primary_keyid { gpg_key.primary_keyid }
+    gpg_key_primary_keyid { gpg_key.keyid }
     verification_status :verified
   end
 end

spec/features/profiles/gpg_keys_spec.rb

@@ -20,6 +20,18 @@ feature 'Profile > GPG Keys' do
       expect(page).to have_content('bette.cartwright@example.net Unverified')
       expect(page).to have_content(GpgHelpers::User2.fingerprint)
     end
+
+    scenario 'with multiple subkeys' do
+      fill_in('Key', with: GpgHelpers::User3.public_key)
+      click_button('Add key')
+
+      expect(page).to have_content('john.doe@example.com Unverified')
+      expect(page).to have_content(GpgHelpers::User3.fingerprint)
+
+      GpgHelpers::User3.subkey_fingerprints.each do |fingerprint|
+        expect(page).to have_content(fingerprint)
+      end
+    end
   end
 
   scenario 'User sees their key' do

spec/lib/gitlab/background_migration/create_gpg_key_subkeys_from_gpg_keys_spec.rb

+require 'spec_helper'
+
+describe Gitlab::BackgroundMigration::CreateGpgKeySubkeysFromGpgKeys, :migration, schema: 20171005130944 do
+  context 'when GpgKey exists' do
+    let!(:gpg_key) { create(:gpg_key, key: GpgHelpers::User3.public_key) }
+
+    before do
+      GpgKeySubkey.destroy_all
+    end
+
+    it 'generate the subkeys' do
+      expect do
+        described_class.new.perform(gpg_key.id)
+      end.to change { gpg_key.subkeys.count }.from(0).to(2)
+    end
+
+    it 'schedules the signature update worker' do
+      expect(InvalidGpgSignatureUpdateWorker).to receive(:perform_async).with(gpg_key.id)
+
+      described_class.new.perform(gpg_key.id)
+    end
+  end
+
+  context 'when GpgKey does not exist' do
+    it 'does not do anything' do
+      expect(Gitlab::Gpg).not_to receive(:subkeys_from_key)
+      expect(InvalidGpgSignatureUpdateWorker).not_to receive(:perform_async)
+
+      described_class.new.perform(123)
+    end
+  end
+end

spec/lib/gitlab/gpg/commit_spec.rb

@@ -63,6 +63,45 @@ describe Gitlab::Gpg::Commit do
           it_behaves_like 'returns the cached signature on second call'
         end
 
+        context 'commit signed with a subkey' do
+          let!(:commit) { create :commit, project: project, sha: commit_sha, committer_email: GpgHelpers::User3.emails.first }
+
+          let!(:user) { create(:user, email: GpgHelpers::User3.emails.first) }
+
+          let!(:gpg_key) do
+            create :gpg_key, key: GpgHelpers::User3.public_key, user: user
+          end
+
+          let(:gpg_key_subkey) do
+            gpg_key.subkeys.find_by(fingerprint: '0522DD29B98F167CD8421752E38FFCAF75ABD92A')
+          end
+
+          before do
+            allow(Rugged::Commit).to receive(:extract_signature)
+            .with(Rugged::Repository, commit_sha)
+            .and_return(
+              [
+                GpgHelpers::User3.signed_commit_signature,
+                GpgHelpers::User3.signed_commit_base_data
+              ]
+            )
+          end
+
+          it 'returns a valid signature' do
+            expect(described_class.new(commit).signature).to have_attributes(
+              commit_sha: commit_sha,
+              project: project,
+              gpg_key: gpg_key_subkey,
+              gpg_key_primary_keyid: gpg_key_subkey.keyid,
+              gpg_key_user_name: GpgHelpers::User3.names.first,
+              gpg_key_user_email: GpgHelpers::User3.emails.first,
+              verification_status: 'verified'
+            )
+          end
+
+          it_behaves_like 'returns the cached signature on second call'
+        end
+
         context 'user email does not match the committer email, but is the same user' do
           let!(:commit) { create :commit, project: project, sha: commit_sha, committer_email: GpgHelpers::User2.emails.first }
 

spec/lib/gitlab/gpg/invalid_gpg_signature_updater_spec.rb

@@ -2,17 +2,16 @@ require 'rails_helper'
 
 RSpec.describe Gitlab::Gpg::InvalidGpgSignatureUpdater do
   describe '#run' do
+    let(:signature)       { [GpgHelpers::User1.signed_commit_signature, GpgHelpers::User1.signed_commit_base_data] }
+    let(:committer_email) { GpgHelpers::User1.emails.first }
     let!(:commit_sha)     { '0beec7b5ea3f0fdbc95d0dd47f3c5bc275da8a33' }
     let!(:project)        { create :project, :repository, path: 'sample-project' }
     let!(:raw_commit) do
       raw_commit = double(
         :raw_commit,
-        signature: [
-          GpgHelpers::User1.signed_commit_signature,
-          GpgHelpers::User1.signed_commit_base_data
-        ],
+        signature: signature,
         sha: commit_sha,
-        committer_email: GpgHelpers::User1.emails.first
+        committer_email: committer_email
       )
 
       allow(raw_commit).to receive :save!
@@ -29,12 +28,7 @@ RSpec.describe Gitlab::Gpg::InvalidGpgSignatureUpdater do
 
       allow(Rugged::Commit).to receive(:extract_signature)
         .with(Rugged::Repository, commit_sha)
-        .and_return(
-          [
-            GpgHelpers::User1.signed_commit_signature,
-            GpgHelpers::User1.signed_commit_base_data
-          ]
-        )
+        .and_return(signature)
     end
 
     context 'gpg signature did have an associated gpg key which was removed later' do
@@ -183,5 +177,34 @@ RSpec.describe Gitlab::Gpg::InvalidGpgSignatureUpdater do
         )
       end
     end
+
+    context 'gpg signature did not have an associated gpg subkey' do
+      let(:signature)       { [GpgHelpers::User3.signed_commit_signature, GpgHelpers::User3.signed_commit_base_data] }
+      let(:committer_email) { GpgHelpers::User3.emails.first }
+      let!(:user)           { create :user, email: GpgHelpers::User3.emails.first }
+
+      let!(:invalid_gpg_signature) do
+        create :gpg_signature,
+          project: project,
+          commit_sha: commit_sha,
+          gpg_key: nil,
+          gpg_key_primary_keyid: GpgHelpers::User3.subkey_fingerprints.last[24..-1],
+          verification_status: 'unknown_key'
+      end
+
+      it 'updates the signature to being valid when the missing gpg key is added' do
+        # InvalidGpgSignatureUpdater is called by the after_create hook
+        gpg_key = create(:gpg_key, key: GpgHelpers::User3.public_key, user: user)
+        subkey = gpg_key.subkeys.last
+
+        expect(invalid_gpg_signature.reload).to have_attributes(
+          project: project,
+          commit_sha: commit_sha,
+          gpg_key_subkey_id: subkey.id,
+          gpg_key_primary_keyid: subkey.keyid,
+          verification_status: 'verified'
+        )
+      end
+    end
   end
 end

spec/lib/gitlab/gpg_spec.rb

@@ -28,6 +28,23 @@ describe Gitlab::Gpg do
     end
   end
 
+  describe '.subkeys_from_key' do
+    it 'returns the subkeys by primary key' do
+      all_subkeys = described_class.subkeys_from_key(GpgHelpers::User1.public_key)
+      subkeys = all_subkeys[GpgHelpers::User1.primary_keyid]
+
+      expect(subkeys).to be_present
+      expect(subkeys.first[:keyid]).to be_present
+      expect(subkeys.first[:fingerprint]).to be_present
+    end
+
+    it 'returns an empty array when there are not subkeys' do
+      all_subkeys = described_class.subkeys_from_key(GpgHelpers::User4.public_key)
+
+      expect(all_subkeys[GpgHelpers::User4.primary_keyid]).to be_empty
+    end
+  end
+
   describe '.user_infos_from_key' do
     it 'returns the names and emails' do
       user_infos = described_class.user_infos_from_key(GpgHelpers::User1.public_key)

spec/migrations/schedule_create_gpg_key_subkeys_from_gpg_keys_spec.rb

+require 'spec_helper'
+require Rails.root.join('db', 'post_migrate', '20171005130944_schedule_create_gpg_key_subkeys_from_gpg_keys')
+
+describe ScheduleCreateGpgKeySubkeysFromGpgKeys, :migration, :sidekiq do
+  matcher :be_scheduled_migration do |*expected|
+    match do |migration|
+      BackgroundMigrationWorker.jobs.any? do |job|
+        job['args'] == [migration, expected]
+      end
+    end
+
+    failure_message do |migration|
+      "Migration `#{migration}` with args `#{expected.inspect}` not scheduled!"
+    end
+  end
+
+  before do
+    create(:gpg_key, id: 1, key: GpgHelpers::User1.public_key)
+    create(:gpg_key, id: 2, key: GpgHelpers::User3.public_key)
+    # Delete all subkeys so they can be recreated
+    GpgKeySubkey.destroy_all
+  end
+
+  it 'correctly schedules background migrations' do
+    Sidekiq::Testing.fake! do
+      migrate!
+
+      expect(described_class::MIGRATION).to be_scheduled_migration(1)
+      expect(described_class::MIGRATION).to be_scheduled_migration(2)
+      expect(BackgroundMigrationWorker.jobs.size).to eq(2)
+    end
+  end
+
+  it 'schedules background migrations' do
+    Sidekiq::Testing.inline! do
+      expect(GpgKeySubkey.count).to eq(0)
+
+      migrate!
+
+      expect(GpgKeySubkey.count).to eq(3)
+    end
+  end
+end

spec/models/gpg_key_spec.rb

@@ -3,6 +3,7 @@ require 'rails_helper'
 describe GpgKey do
   describe "associations" do
     it { is_expected.to belong_to(:user) }
+    it { is_expected.to have_many(:subkeys) }
   end
 
   describe "validation" do
@@ -38,6 +39,14 @@ describe GpgKey do
         expect(gpg_key.primary_keyid).to eq GpgHelpers::User1.primary_keyid
       end
     end
+
+    describe 'generate_subkeys' do
+      it 'extracts the subkeys from the gpg key' do
+        gpg_key = create(:gpg_key, key: GpgHelpers::User1.public_key_with_extra_signing_key)
+
+        expect(gpg_key.subkeys.count).to eq(2)
+      end
+    end
   end
 
   describe '#key=' do
@@ -182,5 +191,29 @@ describe GpgKey do
 
       expect(unrelated_gpg_key.destroyed?).to be false
     end
+
+    it 'deletes all the associated subkeys' do
+      gpg_key = create :gpg_key, key: GpgHelpers::User3.public_key
+
+      expect(gpg_key.subkeys).to be_present
+
+      gpg_key.revoke
+
+      expect(gpg_key.subkeys(true)).to be_blank
+    end
+
+    it 'invalidates all signatures associated to the subkeys' do
+      gpg_key = create :gpg_key, key: GpgHelpers::User3.public_key
+      gpg_key_subkey = gpg_key.subkeys.last
+      gpg_signature = create :gpg_signature, verification_status: :verified, gpg_key: gpg_key_subkey
+
+      gpg_key.revoke
+
+      expect(gpg_signature.reload).to have_attributes(
+        verification_status: 'unknown_key',
+        gpg_key: nil,
+        gpg_key_subkey: nil
+      )
+    end
   end
 end

spec/models/gpg_key_subkey_spec.rb

+require 'rails_helper'
+
+describe GpgKeySubkey do
+  subject { build(:gpg_key_subkey) }
+
+  describe 'associations' do
+    it { is_expected.to belong_to(:gpg_key) }
+  end
+
+  describe 'validations' do
+    it { is_expected.to validate_presence_of(:gpg_key_id) }
+    it { is_expected.to validate_presence_of(:fingerprint) }
+    it { is_expected.to validate_presence_of(:keyid) }
+  end
+end

spec/models/gpg_signature_spec.rb

 require 'rails_helper'
 
 RSpec.describe GpgSignature do
+  let(:gpg_key) { create(:gpg_key) }
+  let(:gpg_key_subkey) { create(:gpg_key_subkey) }
+
   describe 'associations' do
     it { is_expected.to belong_to(:project) }
     it { is_expected.to belong_to(:gpg_key) }
+    it { is_expected.to belong_to(:gpg_key_subkey) }
   end
 
   describe 'validation' do
@@ -25,4 +29,26 @@ RSpec.describe GpgSignature do
       gpg_signature.commit
     end
   end
+
+  describe '#gpg_key=' do
+    it 'supports the assignment of a GpgKey' do
+      gpg_signature = create(:gpg_signature, gpg_key: gpg_key)
+
+      expect(gpg_signature.gpg_key).to be_an_instance_of(GpgKey)
+    end
+
+    it 'supports the assignment of a GpgKeySubkey' do
+      gpg_signature = create(:gpg_signature, gpg_key: gpg_key_subkey)
+
+      expect(gpg_signature.gpg_key).to be_an_instance_of(GpgKeySubkey)
+    end
+
+    it 'clears gpg_key and gpg_key_subkey_id when passing nil' do
+      gpg_signature = create(:gpg_signature, gpg_key: gpg_key_subkey)
+      gpg_signature.update_attribute(:gpg_key, nil)
+
+      expect(gpg_signature.gpg_key_id).to be_nil
+      expect(gpg_signature.gpg_key_subkey_id).to be_nil
+    end
+  end
 end

spec/services/gpg_keys/create_service_spec.rb

@@ -18,4 +18,14 @@ describe GpgKeys::CreateService do
   it 'creates a gpg key' do
     expect { subject.execute }.to change { user.gpg_keys.where(params).count }.by(1)
   end
+
+  context 'when the public key contains subkeys' do
+    let(:params) { attributes_for(:gpg_key_with_subkeys) }
+
+    it 'generates the gpg subkeys' do
+      gpg_key = subject.execute
+
+      expect(gpg_key.subkeys.count).to eq(2)
+    end
+  end
 end

spec/support/gpg_helpers.rb

@@ -92,6 +92,46 @@ module GpgHelpers
       KEY
     end
 
+    def public_key_with_extra_signing_key
+      <<~KEY.strip
+        -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
+        Version: GnuPG v1
+
+        mI0EWK7VJwEEANSFayuVYenl7sBKUjmIxwDRc3jd+K+FWUZgknLgiLcevaLh/mxV
+        98dLxDKGDHHNKc/B7Y4qdlZYv1wfNQVuIbd8dqUQFOOkH7ukbgcGBTxH+2IM67y+
+        QBH618luS5Gz1d4bd0YoFf/xZGEh9G5xicz7TiXYzLKjnMjHu2EmbFePABEBAAG0
+        LU5hbm5pZSBCZXJuaGFyZCA8bmFubmllLmJlcm5oYXJkQGV4YW1wbGUuY29tPoi4
+        BBMBAgAiBQJYrtUnAhsDBgsJCAcDAgYVCAIJCgsEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRDM++Gf
+        AKyLHaeSA/99oUWpb02PlfkALcx5RncboMHkgczYEU9wOFIgvXIReswThCMOvPZa
+        piui+ItyJfV3ijJfO8IvbbFcvU7jjGA073Bb7tbzAEOQLA16mWgBLQlGaRWbHDW4
+        uwFxvkJKA0GzEsadEXeniESaZPc4rOXKPO3+/MSQWS2bmvvGsBTEuriNBFiu1ScB
+        BADIXkITf+kKCkD+n8tMsdTLInefu8KrJ8p7YRYCCabEXnWRsDb5zxUAG2VXCVUh
+        Yl6QXQybkNiBaduS+uxilz7gtYZUMFJvQ09+fV7D2N9B7u/1bGdIYz+cDFJnEJit
+        LY4w/nju2Sno5CL5Ead8sZuslKetSXPYHR/kbW462EOw5wARAQABiJ8EGAECAAkF
+        Aliu1ScCGwwACgkQzPvhnwCsix2WRQQAtOXpBS60myrBUXhlcqabDQgSTw+Spbgb
+        61hEMckyzpk7SfMNLz0EbYMvj9SU6znBG8RGeUljPTVMxPGr9yIpoFMSPKAUi/0K
+        AgRmH3tVpxlMipwXjST1Jukk2eHckt/3jGw3E1ElMSFtULe6u5p4gu578hHukEwT
+        IKzj0ZyC7DK5AQ0EWcx23AEIANwpAq85bT10JCBuNhOMyF2jKVt5wHbI9wBtjWYG
+        fgJFBkRvm6IsbmR0Y5DSBvF/of0UX1iGMfx6mvCDJkb1okquhCUef6MONWRpzXYE
+        CIZDm1TXu6yv0D35tkLfPo+/sY9UHHp1zGRcPAU46e8ztRwoD+zEJwy7lobLHGOL
+        9OdWtCGjsutLOTqKRK4jsifr8n3rePU09rejhDkRONNs7ufn9GRcWMN7RWiFDtpU
+        gNe84AJ38qaXPU8GHNTrDtDtRRPmn68ezMmE1qTNsxQxD4Isexe5Wsfc4+ElaP9s
+        zaHgij7npX1HS9RpmhnOa2h1ESroM9cqDh3IJVhf+eP6/uMAEQEAAYkBxAQYAQIA
+        DwUCWcx23AIbAgUJAeEzgAEpCRDM++GfAKyLHcBdIAQZAQIABgUCWcx23AAKCRDk
+        garE0uOuES7DCAC2Kgl6zO+NqIBIS6McgcEN0sGyvOvZ8Ps4hBiMwCyDAnsIRAUi
+        v4KZMtQMAyl9njJ3YjPWBsdieuTz45O06DDnrzJpZO5rUGJjAcEue4zvRRWIyu3H
+        qHC8MsvkslsNCygJHoWlknm+HucroskTNtxHQ+FdKZ6Tey+twl1u+PhV8PQVyFkl
+        4G1chO90EP4dvYrye26CC+ik2JkvC7Vy5M+U0PJikme8pFMjcdNks25BnAKcdqKU
+        AU8RTkSjoYvb8qSmZyldJjYjQRkTPRX1ZdaOID1EdiWl+s5cn0Oypo3z7BChcEMx
+        IWB/gmXQJQXVr5qNQnJObyMO/RczXYi9qNnyGMED/2EJJERLR0nefjHQalwDKQVP
+        s5lX1OKAcf2CrV6ZarckqaQgtqjZbuV2C2mrOHUs5uojlXaopj5gA4yJSGDcYhj1
+        Rg9jdHWBtkHBj3eL32ZqrHDs3ap8ErZMmPE8A+mn9TTnQS+FY2QF7vBjJKM3qPT7
+        DMVGWrg4m1NF8N6yMPMP
+        =RB1y
+        -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
+      KEY
+    end
+
     def primary_keyid
       fingerprint[-16..-1]
     end
@@ -201,4 +241,277 @@ module GpgHelpers
       ['bette.cartwright@example.com', 'bette.cartwright@example.net']
     end
   end
+
+  # GPG Key with extra signing key
+  module User3
+    extend self
+
+    def signed_commit_signature
+      <<~SIGNATURE
+        -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
+
+        iQEzBAABCAAdFiEEBSLdKbmPFnzYQhdS44/8r3Wr2SoFAlnNlT8ACgkQ44/8r3Wr
+        2SqP1wf9FC4J2S8LIHs/fpxgkYzsyCp5lCbS7JuoD4pqmI2KWyBx+vi9/3mZPCsm
+        Fj9f0vFEtNOb39GNGZbaA8DdGw30/WAS6kI6yco0WSK53KHrLw9Kqd+3e/NAVSsl
+        991Gq4n8X1U5izSH+gZOMtEEUBGqIlZKgRrEh7lhNcz0G7JTF2VCE4NNtZdq7GDA
+        N6jOQxDGUwi9wQBYORQzIBc3NihfhGloII1hXf0XzrgUY3zNYHTT7QipCxKAmH54
+        skwW+wi8RpBedar4saf7fs5xZbP/0yyVz98MJMdHBL68++Xt1AIHoqrb7eWszqnd
+        PCo/fnz1iHKCig602KLj0/zhADcNkg==
+        =LsTi
+        -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
+      SIGNATURE
+    end
+
+    def signed_commit_base_data
+      <<~SIGNEDDATA
+        tree 86ec18bfe87ad42a782fdabd8310f9b7ac750f51
+        parent 2d1096e3a0ecf1d2baf6dee036cc80775d4940ba
+        author John Doe <john.doe@example.com> 1506645311 -0500
+        committer John Doe <john.doe@example.com> 1506645311 -0500
+
+        Commit signed with subkey by John Doe
+      SIGNEDDATA
+    end
+
+    def public_key
+      <<~KEY.strip
+        -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
+
+        mQENBFnNgbIBCAC9/WblcR4s/pFTwh9cm2iS59YRhtGfbrnfNE6QMIFIRFaK0u6J
+        LDy+scipXLoGg7X0XNFLW6Y457UUpkaPDVLPuVMONhMXdVqndGVvk9jq3D4oDtRa
+        ukucuXr9F84lHnjL3EosmAUiK3xBmHOGHm8+bvKbgPOdvre48YxoJ1POTen+chfo
+        YtLUfnC9EEGY/bn00aaXm3NV+zZK2zio5bFX9YLWSNh/JaXxuJsLoHR/lVrU7CLt
+        FCaGcPQ9SU46LHPshEYWO7ZsjEYJsYYOIOEzfcfR47T2EDTa6mVc++gC5TCoY3Ql
+        jccgm+EM0LvyEHwupEpxzCg2VsT0yoedhUhtABEBAAG0H0pvaG4gRG9lIDxqb2hu
+        LmRvZUBleGFtcGxlLmNvbT6JAVQEEwEIAD4WIQTqP4uIlyqP1HSHLy8RWzrxqtPt
+        ugUCWc2BsgIbAwUJA8JnAAULCQgHAgYVCAkKCwIEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRARWzrx
+        qtPturMDCACc1Pi1sLJFcCnJEc9sCInCO4LH8fntNjRLN3MTPU5YCYmFM3fAl5ly
+        vXPZ4jNWZxKbQVeFnkDOg5Ti8bzmFEMc8KbZuguktVFizxnLdFCTTRO89i3HDVSN
+        bIosrs5HJwRKOzul6i2whn3dsr8/P8WJczYjZGiw29hGwH3md4Thn/aAGbzjoCEF
+        IfIb1kccyHMJkaj79S8B2agsbEJLuTSfsXC3kGZIJyKG1DNmDUHW/ZE6ro/Kkhik
+        3w6Jw14cMsKUIOBkOgsD/gXgX9xxWjYHmKrbCXucTKUevNlaCy5tzwrC0Am3prl9
+        OJj3macOA8hNaTVDflEHNCwHOwqnVQYyuQENBFnNgbIBCAC59MmKc0cqPRPTpCZ5
+        arKRoj23SNKWMDWaxSELdU91Wd/NJk4wF25urk9BtBuwjzaBMqb/xPD88yJC3ucs
+        2LwCyAb5C/dHcPOpys8Pd+KrdHDR3zAMjcASsizlW/qFI9MtjhcU9Yd6iTUejAZG
+        NEC76WALJ3SLYzCaDkHFjWpH3Xq6ck3/9jpL3csn/5GLCsZQUDYGrZSXvHAIigwW
+        Xo6tMs5LCCO9CZg2qGDpvqlzcmy6CRkf0h/UFYJzGqfbJtxeCIxa93WIPE8eGwao
+        aneDlNtIoYiP6krC3OLsaPWT58QltNKaQuZSpjwtQBHa4JIt55vx+FcvRb7Kflgf
+        fT8bABEBAAGJATwEGAEIACYWIQTqP4uIlyqP1HSHLy8RWzrxqtPtugUCWc2BsgIb
+        DAUJA8JnAAAKCRARWzrxqtPtuqJjCACj+Z4qtgMpJXx3u58wCzkVLl5IylD/tEPA
+        cNIrj8QS8ec+woTJaMGVCh96VC2FPl8KR4Hjhy0yaupyPbTI6VWib63S/NcDfG7r
+        tviRFG2Gf8yduERebyC0cpgnmjVgFfJs7N3K3ncz6myOr9idNI05OC9poL73sDUv
+        jRXhm7uy938bT/R4MQdpYuxucgU3MiwvfG5ht+oJ4Yp+/IrR2PTqRGqMCsodnroa
+        TBKq2kW565TtCvrFkNub/ytorDbIVN9VrIMcuTiOv8sLoQRDJO9HvWUhYAqMY6Uh
+        dy12jR9FrquZnGsDKKs9V0Y6J4Wi8vnmdgWVZUc40pfXq3APAB6suQENBFnNgeAB
+        CADFqQRxLHxLIQ7B72diTMI2tPk9d5c67k+Gzkrg1QYoxBLdRCmhM4ydYqZzvIz4
+        1npkK20w4somOCwvyAOjO46IGb3f/Wk8mY8o5HMpI1miAfze0YTZKzRo2DmrvwbV
+        /h8jvZNCISwtrOgaaszWSVSuEQQCA1jf4qixfCb3ReETvZc3MTZXhw8IUbszXh5d
+        a6CYqq/fr5Zw4Dc19ZSoHSTh0Wn03mEm/kaYtia/wt1I+xVvTSaC2Pf/kUtr7UEf
+        3NMc0YF0s4KgeW8KwjHa7Sz9wzydLPRH5kJ26SDUGUhrFf1jNLIegtDsoISV/86G
+        ztXcVq5GY6lXMwmsggRe++7xABEBAAGJAmwEGAEIACAWIQTqP4uIlyqP1HSHLy8R
+        WzrxqtPtugUCWc2B4AIbAgFACRARWzrxqtPtusB0IAQZAQgAHRYhBAUi3Sm5jxZ8
+        2EIXUuOP/K91q9kqBQJZzYHgAAoJEOOP/K91q9kqlHcH+wbvD14ITYDMfgIfy67O
+        4Qcmgf1qzGXhpsABz/i/EPgRD990eNBI0YGuvoKRJfetEGn7LerrrCB8Z+ICFPHF
+        rzXoe10zm+QTREck0OB8nPFRycJ+Fbl6JX+cnkEx27Mmg1aVb7+H5LMDaWO1KjLs
+        g2wIDo/jrDfW7NoZzy4XTd7jFCOt4fftL/dhiujQmhLzugZXCxRISOVdmgilDJQo
+        Tz1sEm34ida98JFjdzSgkUvJ/pFTZ21ThCNxlUf01Hr2Pdcg1e2/97sZocMFTY2J
+        KwmiW2LG3B05/VrRtdvsCVj8G49coxgPPKty+m71ovAXdS/CvVqE7TefCplsYJ1d
+        V3abwwf/Xl2SxzbAKbrYMgZfdGzpPg2u6982WvfGIVfjFJh9veHZAbfkPcjdAD2X
+        e67Y4BeKG2OQQqeOY2y+81A7PaehgHzbFHJG/4RjqB66efrZAg4DgIdbr4oyMoUJ
+        VVsl0wfYSIvnd4kvWXYICVwk53HLA3wIowZAsJ1LT2byAKbUzayLzTekrTzGcwQk
+        g2XT798ev2QuR5Ki5x8MULBFX4Lhd03+uGOxjhNPQD6DAAHCQLaXQhaGuyMgt5hD
+        t0nF3yuw3Eg4Ygcbtm24rZXOHJc9bDKeRiWZz1dIyYYVJmHSQwOVXkAwJlF1sIgy
+        /jQYeOgFDKq20x86WulkvsUtBoaZJg==
+        =Q5Z7
+        -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
+      KEY
+    end
+
+    def secret_key
+      <<~SECRET
+        -----BEGIN PGP PRIVATE KEY BLOCK-----
+
+        lQPGBFnNgbIBCAC9/WblcR4s/pFTwh9cm2iS59YRhtGfbrnfNE6QMIFIRFaK0u6J
+        LDy+scipXLoGg7X0XNFLW6Y457UUpkaPDVLPuVMONhMXdVqndGVvk9jq3D4oDtRa
+        ukucuXr9F84lHnjL3EosmAUiK3xBmHOGHm8+bvKbgPOdvre48YxoJ1POTen+chfo
+        YtLUfnC9EEGY/bn00aaXm3NV+zZK2zio5bFX9YLWSNh/JaXxuJsLoHR/lVrU7CLt
+        FCaGcPQ9SU46LHPshEYWO7ZsjEYJsYYOIOEzfcfR47T2EDTa6mVc++gC5TCoY3Ql
+        jccgm+EM0LvyEHwupEpxzCg2VsT0yoedhUhtABEBAAH+BwMCOqjIWtWBMo3mjIP1
+        OnIbZ+YJxSUZ/B8wU2loMv4XiKmeXLbjD6h3jojxYlnreSHA9QvoY8uNaWElL/n2
+        jv6bxluivk8tA9FWJVv4HaSlMDd2J2YmUW17r8z9Kvm7b7pFVSrEoYV93Wdj5FJ7
+        ciKrFhYNSD7tH1sHwkrFAbiv6aHyk9h48YmR3kx2wBvz+pWk7M2srCJx2b6DXkj/
+        fsj1c/vnzUUGooOJgOvYAWrpg/rJUNxSsFypAHf8Xtk+xt8S1aZ9jaCmYk6I1B2L
+        m00HP43cXUpKcmETW1zXvfMLKjjoUEAJhSJhbCwiEzGL4ojQTarl8qbb+MisakEJ
+        DkPYtrhiiuVzUIFfqE86yO0UKidtzBmJAW3c6zeiUATvACzU09aGyUY1cJi93oXD
+        w4PCyVZ+nMvGD1wx+gyYdDINwpX4y6od9RDr06DGCzwu+S2vxsu1T8LdSv52fhBr
+        U0FY3Z3VN1ytay4SHi/8Y9VBYQFBh7R7Ch0gEMxLVKXVNqOXHUdGrKWV/WmyLKuZ
+        W9DEnWU4Mpz/di5jU8EDW7EB9DZZhVk3mQw3nuAZrBGD4azmmD5mgSgLeBGmKZ1e
+        q/9IWO44mRBBUtNv+rAkmmYF3MCNHuc7EMj+c/IgBUC7d5qBzGWA3UJ0vKX4xcIQ
+        X/PnU+nGxNvBrdqQaMLczeg28SerojxuX79prOsoySctLAbajd9HshW5SfOZ0rvb
+        BNHPqolQDijYEHGxANh4BbamRMGi60Rop7vJsZOLAemz17x/mvCtAHISOJT77/IM
+        oWC+IksJ5XsA/klJGe/tkx11aRQDDmKvIJXmMuRdvnIR23UBbzRQlWWq0l6CdoF6
+        6SQ9BJBFq0WY32No9WZAPnDO3buUzWc1Y3uwn/+h7TVYVyTlEqzpYJ9FoJwBHbor
+        0663eoyz6+AUtB9Kb2huIERvZSA8am9obi5kb2VAZXhhbXBsZS5jb20+iQFUBBMB
+        CAA+FiEE6j+LiJcqj9R0hy8vEVs68arT7boFAlnNgbICGwMFCQPCZwAFCwkIBwIG
+        FQgJCgsCBBYCAwECHgECF4AACgkQEVs68arT7bqzAwgAnNT4tbCyRXApyRHPbAiJ
+        wjuCx/H57TY0SzdzEz1OWAmJhTN3wJeZcr1z2eIzVmcSm0FXhZ5AzoOU4vG85hRD
+        HPCm2boLpLVRYs8Zy3RQk00TvPYtxw1UjWyKLK7ORycESjs7peotsIZ93bK/Pz/F
+        iXM2I2RosNvYRsB95neE4Z/2gBm846AhBSHyG9ZHHMhzCZGo+/UvAdmoLGxCS7k0
+        n7Fwt5BmSCcihtQzZg1B1v2ROq6PypIYpN8OicNeHDLClCDgZDoLA/4F4F/ccVo2
+        B5iq2wl7nEylHrzZWgsubc8KwtAJt6a5fTiY95mnDgPITWk1Q35RBzQsBzsKp1UG
+        Mp0DxgRZzYGyAQgAufTJinNHKj0T06QmeWqykaI9t0jSljA1msUhC3VPdVnfzSZO
+        MBdubq5PQbQbsI82gTKm/8Tw/PMiQt7nLNi8AsgG+Qv3R3DzqcrPD3fiq3Rw0d8w
+        DI3AErIs5Vv6hSPTLY4XFPWHeok1HowGRjRAu+lgCyd0i2Mwmg5BxY1qR916unJN
+        //Y6S93LJ/+RiwrGUFA2Bq2Ul7xwCIoMFl6OrTLOSwgjvQmYNqhg6b6pc3JsugkZ
+        H9If1BWCcxqn2ybcXgiMWvd1iDxPHhsGqGp3g5TbSKGIj+pKwtzi7Gj1k+fEJbTS
+        mkLmUqY8LUAR2uCSLeeb8fhXL0W+yn5YH30/GwARAQAB/gcDAuYn/gmAA3OC5p5Q
+        Pat5kE7MtmSvSPmdjVA2o+6RtqZf81JqtAgtDVDwj7SPFsH6ue5P+iAn9938YYek
+        WQU2+0GXeUbSJt+u4VAchgwA5mYsEnEr1/E5KEfWPWO3jJol1rJG99adrjkMxvug
+        QJmwieqhu0368w1FU0tKstxYbr3Tz3nPCPDJoigMEUkXiFklDCUgeNk0g+zd5ytE
+        lXuuLYcGZX7njxL5jD+cMIKqua5zv8WbvNf/BhM1nCarxp4qzKWim8J8jY+iR+/E
+        qOar4aliGRez0j+qh/r8ywgPwfOO89zrKrMfaclL7dN9yuecmBHKWZvfrP5JKMHj
+        yTU3nRMhUGbfVUaaZI2Ccz2rNOU4oF9wuzpzQi8qOysZixRmH61Nw3ULIKoQgiWp
+        0p5A3L94OaEfZEq3plVaIXI2YWYFSEAlIAc2dq4GxynousLdhNACi9bHhXrfFUhK
+        ckw1QlbhguO/j63/x8ygsmLZVwHG0fJZtMhT3+EGam9cuMBibIYyu3ufJRy7kMKt
+        kmyuk02X+hYJ7w8Pu6b8zYHBXbsEKamipMgd4oKtc8WnXILZo4lwDSArgs7ZVCBa
+        vGBbpTOsr54WjsyuCdX/wv0F2l31J87UxVtTKXx/+nfMfCE02zd+NsTgqvgqmkaA
+        Sy3qvv326kJNx7p+5hRwDzlAZ7vGJjj5TwCbGYDvctIf6MFrGDRNYwrGwNkPc3TG
+        rturfeL/ioua0Smj8LIbOv9Ir93gUIseNpxv8tXV/lffdIplcw802b3aXIKyv4fq
+        b9y3Oq/pDHFukKuBe9WTXJvjT0+ME+a0C8KIb/sts95pmjZsgN1kPmvuT0ReQwUR
+        eGrqz387bnVUzo4RgM3IERs/0EYzPzE8A2vc1e4/87b5J+1Xnov8Phd29vW8Td5l
+        ApiFrFO2r+/Np4kBPAQYAQgAJhYhBOo/i4iXKo/UdIcvLxFbOvGq0+26BQJZzYGy
+        AhsMBQkDwmcAAAoJEBFbOvGq0+26omMIAKP5niq2AyklfHe7nzALORUuXkjKUP+0
+        Q8Bw0iuPxBLx5z7ChMlowZUKH3pULYU+XwpHgeOHLTJq6nI9tMjpVaJvrdL81wN8
+        buu2+JEUbYZ/zJ24RF5vILRymCeaNWAV8mzs3credzPqbI6v2J00jTk4L2mgvvew
+        NS+NFeGbu7L3fxtP9HgxB2li7G5yBTcyLC98bmG36gnhin78itHY9OpEaowKyh2e
+        uhpMEqraRbnrlO0K+sWQ25v/K2isNshU31Wsgxy5OI6/ywuhBEMk70e9ZSFgCoxj
+        pSF3LXaNH0Wuq5mcawMoqz1XRjonhaLy+eZ2BZVlRzjSl9ercA8AHqydA8YEWc2B
+        4AEIAMWpBHEsfEshDsHvZ2JMwja0+T13lzruT4bOSuDVBijEEt1EKaEzjJ1ipnO8
+        jPjWemQrbTDiyiY4LC/IA6M7jogZvd/9aTyZjyjkcykjWaIB/N7RhNkrNGjYOau/
+        BtX+HyO9k0IhLC2s6BpqzNZJVK4RBAIDWN/iqLF8JvdF4RO9lzcxNleHDwhRuzNe
+        Hl1roJiqr9+vlnDgNzX1lKgdJOHRafTeYSb+Rpi2Jr/C3Uj7FW9NJoLY9/+RS2vt
+        QR/c0xzRgXSzgqB5bwrCMdrtLP3DPJ0s9EfmQnbpINQZSGsV/WM0sh6C0OyghJX/
+        zobO1dxWrkZjqVczCayCBF777vEAEQEAAf4HAwKESvCIDq5QNeadnSvpkZemItPO
+        lDf+7Wiue2gt776D5xkVyT7WkgTQv+IGWGtqz7pCCO2rMp/F9u1BghdjY46jtrK6
+        MMFKta4YENUhRliH6M2YmRjq5p7xZgH6UOnDlqsafbfyUx30t59tbQj+07aMnH5J
+        LMm37nVkDvo3wpPQPuo7L6qizYsrHrQKeJZ8636u41UjC99lVH7vXzqXw68FJImi
+        XdMZbEVBIprYfCDem+fD6gJBA4JBqWJMxuFMfhWp+1WtYoeNojDm4KxBzc2fvYV/
+        HOIUfLFBvACD/UwU5ovllHN39/O8SMgyLm9ymx2/qXcdIkUz4l7fhOCY1OW12DMu
+        5OFrrTteGK/Sj4Z8pYRdMdaKyjIlxuVzEQGWsU5+J2ALao5atEHguqwlD3cKh3G8
+        1sA/l5eTFDt84erYv1MVStV0BhZaCE4mNL4WpnQGDdW05yoGq9jIyLcurb/k/atU
+        TUkAF1csgNlJlR3IP+7U9xfHkjMO5+SV82xoNf9nBjz06TRdnvOSKsMNKp0RxC/L
+        Hbiee9o7Rxqdiyv0ly6bCCymwfvlsEIqo3YKssBfe3XI5yQI2hF9QZaH1ywzmgaH
+        o+rbME/XxddRJueS79eipT7K05Z3ulSHTXzpDw+jZcdUV0Ac72Q9FTDPMl3xc6NW
+        DrYwWw/3+kyZ4SkP56l7KlGczTyNPvU9iou4Cj/cAZk/pHx68Chq8ZZNznFm/bIF
+        gWt3fqE/n+y78B6MI8qTjGJOR0jycxrLH82Z2F+FpMShI2C5NnOa/Ilkv3e2Q5U6
+        MOAwaCIz6RHhcI99O/yta2vLelWZqn2g86rLzTG0HlIABTCPYotwetHh0hsrkSv9
+        Kh6rOzGB4i8lRqcBVY+alMSiRBlzkwpL4YUcO6f3vEDncQ9evE1AQCpD4jUJjB1H
+        JSSJAmwEGAEIACAWIQTqP4uIlyqP1HSHLy8RWzrxqtPtugUCWc2B4AIbAgFACRAR
+        WzrxqtPtusB0IAQZAQgAHRYhBAUi3Sm5jxZ82EIXUuOP/K91q9kqBQJZzYHgAAoJ
+        EOOP/K91q9kqlHcH+wbvD14ITYDMfgIfy67O4Qcmgf1qzGXhpsABz/i/EPgRD990
+        eNBI0YGuvoKRJfetEGn7LerrrCB8Z+ICFPHFrzXoe10zm+QTREck0OB8nPFRycJ+
+        Fbl6JX+cnkEx27Mmg1aVb7+H5LMDaWO1KjLsg2wIDo/jrDfW7NoZzy4XTd7jFCOt
+        4fftL/dhiujQmhLzugZXCxRISOVdmgilDJQoTz1sEm34ida98JFjdzSgkUvJ/pFT
+        Z21ThCNxlUf01Hr2Pdcg1e2/97sZocMFTY2JKwmiW2LG3B05/VrRtdvsCVj8G49c
+        oxgPPKty+m71ovAXdS/CvVqE7TefCplsYJ1dV3abwwf/Xl2SxzbAKbrYMgZfdGzp
+        Pg2u6982WvfGIVfjFJh9veHZAbfkPcjdAD2Xe67Y4BeKG2OQQqeOY2y+81A7Paeh
+        gHzbFHJG/4RjqB66efrZAg4DgIdbr4oyMoUJVVsl0wfYSIvnd4kvWXYICVwk53HL
+        A3wIowZAsJ1LT2byAKbUzayLzTekrTzGcwQkg2XT798ev2QuR5Ki5x8MULBFX4Lh
+        d03+uGOxjhNPQD6DAAHCQLaXQhaGuyMgt5hDt0nF3yuw3Eg4Ygcbtm24rZXOHJc9
+        bDKeRiWZz1dIyYYVJmHSQwOVXkAwJlF1sIgy/jQYeOgFDKq20x86WulkvsUtBoaZ
+        Jg==
+        =TKlF
+        -----END PGP PRIVATE KEY BLOCK-----
+      SECRET
+    end
+
+    def fingerprint
+      'EA3F8B88972A8FD474872F2F115B3AF1AAD3EDBA'
+    end
+
+    def subkey_fingerprints
+      %w(159AD5DDF199591D67D2B87AA3CEC5C0A7C270EC 0522DD29B98F167CD8421752E38FFCAF75ABD92A)
+    end
+
+    def names
+      ['John Doe']
+    end
+
+    def emails
+      ['john.doe@example.com']
+    end
+  end
+
+  # GPG Key containing just the main key
+  module User4
+    extend self
+
+    def public_key
+      <<~KEY.strip
+        -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
+
+        mQENBFnWcesBCAC6Y8FXl9ZJ9HPa6dIYcgQrvjIQcwoQCUEsaXNRpc+206RPCIXK
+        aIYr0nTD8GeovMuUONXTj+DdueQU2GAAqHHOqvDDVXqRrW3xfWnSwix7sTuhG1Ew
+        PLHYmjLENqaTsdyliEo3N8VWy2k0QRbC3R6xvop4Ooa87D5vcATIl0gYFtSiHIL+
+        TervYvTG9Eq1qSLZHbe2x4IzeqX2luikPKokL7j8FTZaCmC5MezIUur1ulfyYY/j
+        SkST/1aUFc5QXJJSZA0MYJWZX6x7Y3l7yl0dkHqmK8OTuo8RPWd3ybEiuvRsOL8K
+        GAv/PmVJRGDAf7GGbwXXsE9MiZ5GzVPxHnexABEBAAG0G0pvaG4gRG9lIDxqb2hu
+        QGV4YW1wbGUuY29tPokBTgQTAQgAOBYhBAh0izYM0lwuzJnVlAcBbPnhOj+bBQJZ
+        1nHrAhsDBQsJCAcCBhUICQoLAgQWAgMBAh4BAheAAAoJEAcBbPnhOj+bkywH/i4w
+        OwpDxoTjUQlPlqGAGuzvWaPzSJndawgmMTr68oRsD+wlQmQQTR5eqxCpUIyV4aYb
+        D697RYzoqbT4mlU49ymzfKSAxFe88r1XQWdm81DcofHVPmw2GBrIqaX3Du4Z7xkI
+        Q9/S43orwknh5FoVwU8Nau7qBuv9vbw2apSkuA1oBj3spQ8hqwLavACyQ+fQloAT
+        hSDNqPiCZj6L0dwM1HYiqVoN3Q7qjgzzeBzlXzljJoWblhxllvMK20bVoa7H+uR2
+        lczFHfsX8VTIMjyTGP7R3oHN91DEahlQybVVNLmNSDKZM2P/0d28BRUmWxQJ4Ws3
+        J4hOWDKnLMed3VOIWzM=
+        =xVuW
+        -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
+      KEY
+    end
+
+    def secret_key
+      <<~KEY.strip
+        -----BEGIN PGP PRIVATE KEY BLOCK-----
+
+        lQPGBFnWcesBCAC6Y8FXl9ZJ9HPa6dIYcgQrvjIQcwoQCUEsaXNRpc+206RPCIXK
+        aIYr0nTD8GeovMuUONXTj+DdueQU2GAAqHHOqvDDVXqRrW3xfWnSwix7sTuhG1Ew
+        PLHYmjLENqaTsdyliEo3N8VWy2k0QRbC3R6xvop4Ooa87D5vcATIl0gYFtSiHIL+
+        TervYvTG9Eq1qSLZHbe2x4IzeqX2luikPKokL7j8FTZaCmC5MezIUur1ulfyYY/j
+        SkST/1aUFc5QXJJSZA0MYJWZX6x7Y3l7yl0dkHqmK8OTuo8RPWd3ybEiuvRsOL8K
+        GAv/PmVJRGDAf7GGbwXXsE9MiZ5GzVPxHnexABEBAAH+BwMC4UwgHgH5Cp7meY39
+        G5Q3GV2xtwADoaAvlOvPOLPK2fQqxQfb4WN4eZECp2wQuMRBMj52c4i9yphab1mQ
+        vOzoPIRGvkcJoxG++OxQ0kRk0C0gX6wM6SGVdb1nQnfZnoJCCU3IwCaSGktkLDs1
+        jwdI+VmXJbSugUbd25bakHQcE2BaNHuRBlQWQfFbhGBy0+uMfNDBZ6FRipBu47hO
+        f/wm/xXuV8N8BSgvNR/qtAqSQI34CdsnWAhMYm9rqmTNyt0nq4dveX+E0YzVn4lH
+        lOEa7cpYeuBwIL8L3EvSPNCICiJlF3gVqiYzyqRElnCkv1OGc0x3W5onY/agHgGZ
+        KYyi/ubOdqqDgBR+eMt0JKSGH2EPxUAGFPY5F37u4erdxH86GzIinAExLSmADiVR
+        KtxluZP6S2KLbETN5uVbrfa+HVcMbbUZaBHHtL+YbY8PqaFUIvIUR1HM2SK7IrFw
+        KuQ8ibRgooyP7VgMNiPzlFpY4NXUv+FXIrNJ6ELuIaENi0izJ7aIbVBM8SijDz6u
+        5EEmodnDvmU2hmQNZJ17TxggE7oeT0rKdDGHM5zBvqZ3deqE9sgKx/aTKcj61ID3
+        M80ZkHPDFazUCohLpYgFN20bYYSmxU4LeNFy8YEiuic8QQKaAFxSf9Lf87UFQwyF
+        dduI1RWEbjMsbEJXwlmGM02ssQHsgoVKwZxijq5A5R1Ul6LowazQ8obPiwRS4NZ4
+        Z+QKDon79MMXiFEeh1jeG/MKKWPxFg3pdtCWhC7WdH4hfkBsCVKf+T58yB2Gzziy
+        fOHvAl7v3PtdZgf1xikF8spGYGCWo4B2lxC79xIflKAb2U6myb5I4dpUYxzxoMxT
+        zxHwxEie3NxzZGUyXSt3LqYe2r4CxWnOCXWjIxxRlLue1BE5Za1ycnDRjgUO24+Z
+        uDQne6KLkhAotBtKb2huIERvZSA8am9obkBleGFtcGxlLmNvbT6JAU4EEwEIADgW
+        IQQIdIs2DNJcLsyZ1ZQHAWz54To/mwUCWdZx6wIbAwULCQgHAgYVCAkKCwIEFgID
+        AQIeAQIXgAAKCRAHAWz54To/m5MsB/4uMDsKQ8aE41EJT5ahgBrs71mj80iZ3WsI
+        JjE6+vKEbA/sJUJkEE0eXqsQqVCMleGmGw+ve0WM6Km0+JpVOPcps3ykgMRXvPK9
+        V0FnZvNQ3KHx1T5sNhgayKml9w7uGe8ZCEPf0uN6K8JJ4eRaFcFPDWru6gbr/b28
+        NmqUpLgNaAY97KUPIasC2rwAskPn0JaAE4Ugzaj4gmY+i9HcDNR2IqlaDd0O6o4M
+        83gc5V85YyaFm5YcZZbzCttG1aGux/rkdpXMxR37F/FUyDI8kxj+0d6BzfdQxGoZ
+        UMm1VTS5jUgymTNj/9HdvAUVJlsUCeFrNyeITlgypyzHnd1TiFsz
+        =/37z
+        -----END PGP PRIVATE KEY BLOCK-----
+      KEY
+    end
+
+    def primary_keyid
+      fingerprint[-16..-1]
+    end
+
+    def fingerprint
+      '08748B360CD25C2ECC99D59407016CF9E13A3F9B'
+    end
+  end
 end