amari.xlog: attach,sync += information about on-service time

We currently emit information about local time in events, and
information about on-service time in messages. Events don't have
information about on-service time and messages don't carry information
about local time. That is mostly ok, since primary xlog setup is to run
on the same machine, where eNB runs because on-service .utc correlates
with .time in events.

However for eNB < 2022-12-01 on-service time includes only .time field
without .utc field with .time representing "time passed since when eNB
was started". This way for enb.xlog streams generated on older systems
it is not possible for xlog.Reader to know the absolute timestamps of
read messages.

To fix this we amend "attach" and "sync" events to carry both local and
on-service times. This way xlog.Reader, after seeing e.g. "sync" with
.time and only .srv_time without .srv_utc, should be able to
correlate local and on-service clocks and to approximate srv_utc as

	srv_utc' = srv_time' + (time - srv_time)

where time and srv_time correspond to last synchronization, and
srv_time' is what xlog.Reader retrieves for a further-read message in
question.

See kirr/xlte!3 for related discussion.

amari/__init__.py

@@ -63,7 +63,8 @@ def connect(ctx, wsuri):  # -> Conn
 class Conn:
     # .wsuri            websocket uri of the service
     # ._ws              websocket connection to service
-    # ._srv_ready_msg   message we got for "ready"
+    # .srv_ready_msg    message we got for "ready"
+    # .t_srv_ready_msg  timestamp of "ready" reception
 
     # ._mu              sync.Mutex
     # ._rxtab           {} msgid -> (request, rx channel)  | None
@@ -76,6 +77,7 @@ class Conn:
     def __init__(conn, ws, wsuri):
         try:
             msg0_raw = ws.recv()
+            t_msg0 = time.now()
             msg0 = json.loads(msg0_raw)
             # TODO also support 'authenticate'
             if msg0['message'] != 'ready':
@@ -86,7 +88,8 @@ class Conn:
 
         conn.wsuri = wsuri
         conn._ws = ws
-        conn._srv_ready_msg = msg0
+        conn.srv_ready_msg   = msg0
+        conn.t_srv_ready_msg = t_msg0
 
         conn._mu         = sync.Mutex()
         conn._rxtab      = {}
@@ -236,12 +239,12 @@ class Conn:
 
     @property
     def srv_type(conn):
-        return conn._srv_ready_msg['type']
+        return conn.srv_ready_msg['type']
 
     @property
     def srv_name(conn):
-        return conn._srv_ready_msg['name']
+        return conn.srv_ready_msg['name']
 
     @property
     def srv_version(conn):
-        return conn._srv_ready_msg['version']
+        return conn.srv_ready_msg['version']

amari/xlog.py

@@ -247,10 +247,19 @@ class _XLogger:
         defer(conn.close)
 
         # emit "service attach"/"service detach"
+        #
+        # on attach, besides name/type/version, also emit everything present
+        # in the first ready message from the service. This should include
+        # "time" and optionally "utc" for releases ≥ 2022-12-01.
         srv_info = {"srv_name": conn.srv_name,
                     "srv_type": conn.srv_type,
                     "srv_version": conn.srv_version}
-        xl.jemit("service attach", srv_info)
+        srv_iattach = srv_info.copy()
+        for k, v in conn.srv_ready_msg.items():
+            if k in {"message", "type", "name", "version"}:
+                continue
+            srv_iattach["srv_"+k] = v
+        xl.jemit("service attach", srv_iattach)
         def _():
             try:
                 raise
@@ -281,18 +290,22 @@ class _XLogger:
 
     def _xlog1(xl, ctx, conn, xmsgsrv_dict, srv_info):
         # req_ queries either amari service directly, or an extra message service.
-        def req_(ctx, query, opts):  # -> resp_raw
+        def req_(ctx, query, opts):  # -> (t_rx, resp, resp_raw)
             if query in xmsgsrv_dict:
                 query_xsrv = xmsgsrv_dict[query]
-                _, resp_raw = query_xsrv.req_(ctx, opts)
+                resp, resp_raw = query_xsrv.req_(ctx, opts)
             else:
-                _, resp_raw = conn.req_(ctx, query, opts)
-            return resp_raw
+                resp, resp_raw = conn.req_(ctx, query, opts)
+            return (time.now(), resp, resp_raw)
 
         # loop emitting requested logspecs
         t0 = time.now()
         tnextv = [0]*len(xl.logspecv)   # [i] - next time to arm for logspecv[i] relative to t0
 
+        t_rx     = conn.t_srv_ready_msg           # time  of last received message
+        srv_time = conn.srv_ready_msg["time"]     # .time in ----//----
+        srv_utc  = conn.srv_ready_msg.get("utc")  # .utc  in ----//----  (present ≥ 2022-12-01)
+
         while 1:
             # go through all logspecs in the order they were given
             # pick logspec with soonest arm time
@@ -331,9 +344,19 @@ class _XLogger:
                     raise ctx.err()
 
             if logspec.query == 'meta.sync':
-                xl.jemit_sync("attached", "periodic", srv_info)
+                # emit sync with srv_time and srv_utc approximated from last
+                # rx'ed message and local clock run since that reception
+                tnow = time.now()
+                isync = srv_info.copy()
+                isync["srv_time"] = srv_time + (tnow - t_rx)
+                if srv_utc is not None:
+                    isync["srv_utc"]  = srv_utc + (tnow - t_rx)
+                xl.jemit_sync("attached", "periodic", isync)
+
             else:
-                resp_raw = req_(ctx, logspec.query, opts)
+                t_rx, resp, resp_raw = req_(ctx, logspec.query, opts)
+                srv_time = resp["time"]
+                srv_utc  = resp.get("utc")
                 xl.emit(resp_raw)
 
 
@@ -459,6 +482,7 @@ class SyncEvent(Event):
     # .state
     # .reason
     # .generator
+    # .srv_time     | None if not present
     pass
 
 
@@ -504,6 +528,18 @@ def read(xr): # -> Event|Message|None
             # message
             assert isinstance(x, Message)
 
+            # provide timestamps for xlog messages generated with eNB < 2022-12-01
+            # there messages come without .utc field and have only .time
+            # we estimate the timestamp from .time and from δ(utc,time) taken from covering sync
+            if x.timestamp is None:
+                if xr._sync is not None  and  xr._sync.srv_time is not None:
+                    # srv_utc' = srv_time' + (time - srv_time)
+                    srv_time_ = x.get1("time", (float,int))  # ParseError if not present
+                    x.timestamp = srv_time_ + (xr._sync.timestamp - xr._sync.srv_time)
+                if x.timestamp is None:
+                    raise ParseError("%s:%d/%s no `utc` and cannot compute "
+                            "timestamp with sync" % (x.pos[0], x.pos[1], '/'.join(x.path)))
+
             # TODO verify messages we get/got against their schedule in covering sync.
             #      Raise LOSError (loss of synchronization) if what we actually see
             #      does not match what sync says it should be.
@@ -569,6 +605,9 @@ def _read1(xr):
             else:
                 x.state  = meta.get1("state",  str)
                 x.reason = meta.get1("reason", str)
+            x.srv_time = None
+            if "srv_time" in meta:
+                x.srv_time = meta.get1("srv_time", (float,int))
             # TODO parse generator -> .logspecv
         return x
 
@@ -578,7 +617,12 @@ def _read1(xr):
         # NOTE .time is internal eNB time using clock originating at eNB startup.
         #      .utc is seconds since epoch counted using OS clock.
         #      .utc field was added in 2022-12-01 - see https://support.amarisoft.com/issues/21934
+        # if there is no .utc - we defer computing .timestamp to ^^^ read
+        # where it might estimate it from .time and sync
+        if "utc" in x:
             x.timestamp = x.get1("utc", (float,int))
+        else:
+            x.timestamp = None
         return x
 
     raise xr._err("invalid xlog entry")

amari/xlog_test.py

@@ -21,6 +21,7 @@
 from xlte.amari import xlog
 from golang import func, defer, b
 import io
+import json
 
 from pytest import raises
 
@@ -172,6 +173,130 @@ def test_Reader_readahead_vs_eof():
     assert _ is None
 
 
+# verify that for xlog stream produced by enb < 2022-12-01 the Reader can build
+# Messages timestamps by itself based on sync.
+@func
+def test_Reader_timestamp_from_sync_wo_utc():
+    def jevent(time, event, args_dict={}):
+        d = {
+            "event":     event,
+            "time" :     time,
+        }
+        d.update(args_dict)
+        return json.dumps({"meta": d})
+
+    def jsync(time, srv_time):
+        d = {
+            "state":     "attached"  if srv_time is not None  else "detached",
+            "reason":    "periodic",
+            "generator": "...",
+        }
+        if srv_time is not None:
+            d['srv_time'] = srv_time
+        return jevent(time, "sync", d)
+
+    assert jsync(1.1, 2.2)  == '{"meta": {"event": "sync", "time": 1.1, "state": "attached", "reason": "periodic", "generator": "...", "srv_time": 2.2}}'
+    assert jsync(1.1, None) == '{"meta": {"event": "sync", "time": 1.1, "state": "detached", "reason": "periodic", "generator": "..."}}'
+
+    def jmsg(srv_time, msg):
+        return json.dumps({"message": msg, "time": srv_time})
+    assert jmsg(123.4, "aaa")  == '{"message": "aaa", "time": 123.4}'
+
+    data = b""
+    def _(line):
+        nonlocal data
+        assert '\n' not in line
+        data += b(line+'\n')
+
+    A = "service attach"
+    D = "service detach"
+    S = "sync"
+    _( jmsg(1, "aaa")    )  # no timestamp: separated from ↓ jsync(1005) by event
+    _( jevent(1002,   A ))
+    _( jmsg(3, "bbb")    )  # have timestamp from ↓ jsync(1005)
+    _( jmsg(4, "ccc")    )  # ----//----
+    _( jsync(1005, 5)    )  # jsync with srv_time
+    _( jmsg(6, "ddd")    )  # have timestamp from ↑ jsync(1005)
+    _( jmsg(7, "eee")    )  # ----//----
+    _( jevent(1008,   D ))
+    _( jmsg(9, "fff")    )  # no timestamp: separated from ↑ jsync(1005) by event,
+                            # and ↓ jsync(1010) has no srv_time
+    _( jsync(1010, None) )  # jsync without srv_time
+    _( jmsg(11, "ggg")   )  # no timestamp
+
+
+    # expect_notime asserts that "no timestamp" error is raised on next read.
+    def expect_notime(xr, lineno):
+        with raises(xlog.ParseError,
+                match=":%d/ no `utc` and cannot compute timestamp with sync" % lineno):
+            _ = xr.read()
+
+    # expect_msg asserts that specified message with specified timestamp reads next.
+    def expect_msg(xr, timestamp, msg):
+        _ = xr.read()
+        assert type(_) is xlog.Message
+        assert _.message   == msg
+        assert _.timestamp == timestamp
+
+    # expect_event asserts that specified event reads next.
+    def expect_event(xr, timestamp, event):
+        _ = xr.read()
+        assert type(_) is (xlog.SyncEvent  if event == "sync"  else xlog.Event)
+        assert _.event     == event
+        assert _.timestamp == timestamp
+
+
+    xr = xlog.Reader(io.BytesIO(data))
+    br = xlog.Reader(io.BytesIO(data), reverse=True)
+    defer(xr.close)
+    defer(br.close)
+
+    expect_notime(xr,    1       )  # aaa
+    expect_event (xr, 1002,   A  )
+    expect_msg   (xr, 1003, "bbb")
+    expect_msg   (xr, 1004, "ccc")
+    expect_event (xr, 1005,   S  )
+    expect_msg   (xr, 1006, "ddd")
+    expect_msg   (xr, 1007, "eee")
+    expect_event (xr, 1008,   D  )
+    expect_notime(xr,    9       )  # fff
+    expect_event (xr, 1010,   S  )
+    expect_notime(xr,   11       )  # ggg
+
+    expect_notime(br,   -1       )  # ggg
+    expect_event (br, 1010,   S  )
+    expect_notime(br,   -3       )  # fff
+    expect_event (br, 1008,   D  )
+    expect_msg   (br, 1007, "eee")
+    expect_msg   (br, 1006, "ddd")
+    expect_event (br, 1005,   S  )
+    expect_msg   (br, 1004, "ccc")
+    expect_msg   (br, 1003, "bbb")
+    expect_event (br, 1002,   A  )
+    expect_notime(br,   -11      )  # aaa
+
+    # extra check that we can get timestamp of first message if proper sync goes after
+    _( jsync(1012, 12)  )
+    _( jmsg(13, "hhh")  )
+    _( jmsg(14, "iii")  )
+    bb = xlog.Reader(io.BytesIO(data), reverse=True)
+    defer(bb.close)
+    expect_msg   (bb, 1014, "iii")
+    expect_msg   (bb, 1013, "hhh")
+    expect_event (bb, 1012,   S  )
+    expect_msg   (bb, 1011, "ggg")  # now has timestamp because it is covered by ↑ sync(1012)
+    expect_event (bb, 1010,   S  )  # after sync(1010) it goes as for br
+    expect_notime(bb, -3-3       )  # fff
+    expect_event (bb, 1008,   D  )
+    expect_msg   (bb, 1007, "eee")
+    expect_msg   (bb, 1006, "ddd")
+    expect_event (bb, 1005,   S  )
+    expect_msg   (bb, 1004, "ccc")
+    expect_msg   (bb, 1003, "bbb")
+    expect_event (bb, 1002,   A  )
+    expect_notime(bb, -3-11      )  # aaa
+
+
 def test_LogSpec():
     logspec = "stats[samples,rf]/60s"
     spec = xlog.LogSpec.parse(logspec)