BUG#17379 Wrong reuse of E(#rows(range)) as E(#rows(ref(const))):

Re-work best_access_path() and find_best() to reuse E(#rows(range access)) as
E(#rows(ref[_or_null](const) access) only when it is appropriate.
[This is the final cumulative patch]


mysql-test/r/select.result:
  BUG#17379: Testcase
mysql-test/r/subselect.result:
  BUG#17379: Updated test results
mysql-test/t/select.test:
  BUG#17379: Testcase
sql/opt_range.cc:
  BUG#17379: Wrong reuse of E(#rows(range)) as E(#rows(ref(const))):
  Make range optimizer together with TABLE::quick_* also return TABLE::quick_n_ranges
sql/sql_select.cc:
  BUG#17379: Wrong reuse of E(#rows(range)) as E(#rows(ref(const))):
  Re-work best_access_path() to reuse E(#rows(range access)) as
  E(#rows(ref[_or_null](const) access) only when it is appropriate.
sql/table.h:
  BUG#17379: Wrong reuse of E(#rows(range)) as E(#rows(ref(const))):
  Make range optimizer together with TABLE::quick_* also return TABLE::quick_n_ranges

mysql-test/r/select.result

@@ -3411,3 +3411,19 @@ SELECT * FROM t1;
 i
 255
 DROP TABLE t1;
+create table t1 (a int);
+insert into t1 values (0),(1),(2),(3),(4),(5),(6),(7),(8),(9);
+create table t2 (a int, b int, c int, e int, primary key(a,b,c));
+insert into t2 select A.a, B.a, C.a, C.a from t1 A, t1 B, t1 C;
+analyze table t2;
+Table	Op	Msg_type	Msg_text
+test.t2	analyze	status	OK
+select 'In next EXPLAIN, B.rows must be exactly 10:' Z;
+Z
+In next EXPLAIN, B.rows must be exactly 10:
+explain select * from t2 A, t2 B where A.a=5 and A.b=5 and A.C<5
+and B.a=5 and B.b=A.e and (B.b =1 or B.b = 3 or B.b=5);
+id	select_type	table	type	possible_keys	key	key_len	ref	rows	Extra
+1	SIMPLE	A	range	PRIMARY	PRIMARY	12	NULL	3	Using where
+1	SIMPLE	B	ref	PRIMARY	PRIMARY	8	const,test.A.e	10	
+drop table t1, t2;

mysql-test/r/subselect.result

@@ -1480,7 +1480,7 @@ Note	1003	select `test`.`t1`.`s1` AS `s1`,not(<in_optimizer>(`test`.`t1`.`s1`,<e
 explain extended select s1, s1 NOT IN (SELECT s1 FROM t2 WHERE s1 < 'a2') from t1;
 id	select_type	table	type	possible_keys	key	key_len	ref	rows	Extra
 1	PRIMARY	t1	index	NULL	s1	6	NULL	3	Using index
-2	DEPENDENT SUBQUERY	t2	index_subquery	s1	s1	6	func	1	Using index; Using where
+2	DEPENDENT SUBQUERY	t2	index_subquery	s1	s1	6	func	2	Using index; Using where
 Warnings:
 Note	1003	select `test`.`t1`.`s1` AS `s1`,not(<in_optimizer>(`test`.`t1`.`s1`,<exists>(<index_lookup>(<cache>(`test`.`t1`.`s1`) in t2 on s1 checking NULL where (`test`.`t2`.`s1` < _latin1'a2'))))) AS `s1 NOT IN (SELECT s1 FROM t2 WHERE s1 < 'a2')` from `test`.`t1`
 drop table t1,t2;

mysql-test/t/select.test

@@ -2886,3 +2886,16 @@ SELECT * FROM t1;
 UPDATE t1 SET i = i - 1;
 SELECT * FROM t1;
 DROP TABLE t1;
+
+# BUG#17379
+
+create table t1 (a int);
+insert into t1 values (0),(1),(2),(3),(4),(5),(6),(7),(8),(9);
+create table t2 (a int, b int, c int, e int, primary key(a,b,c));
+insert into t2 select A.a, B.a, C.a, C.a from t1 A, t1 B, t1 C;
+analyze table t2;
+select 'In next EXPLAIN, B.rows must be exactly 10:' Z;
+
+explain select * from t2 A, t2 B where A.a=5 and A.b=5 and A.C<5
+          and B.a=5 and B.b=A.e and (B.b =1 or B.b = 3 or B.b=5);
+drop table t1, t2;

sql/opt_range.cc

@@ -347,8 +347,10 @@ typedef struct st_qsel_param {
   uint *imerge_cost_buff;     /* buffer for index_merge cost estimates */
   uint imerge_cost_buff_size; /* size of the buffer */
 
- /* TRUE if last checked tree->key can be used for ROR-scan */
+  /* TRUE if last checked tree->key can be used for ROR-scan */
   bool is_ror_scan;
+  /* Number of ranges in the last checked tree->key */
+  uint n_ranges;
 } PARAM;
 
 class TABLE_READ_PLAN;
@@ -5297,6 +5299,7 @@ check_quick_select(PARAM *param,uint idx,SEL_ARG *tree)
                param->table->file->primary_key_is_clustered());
     param->is_ror_scan= !cpk_scan;
   }
+  param->n_ranges= 0;
 
   records=check_quick_keys(param,idx,tree,param->min_key,0,param->max_key,0);
   if (records != HA_POS_ERROR)
@@ -5304,7 +5307,7 @@ check_quick_select(PARAM *param,uint idx,SEL_ARG *tree)
     param->table->quick_keys.set_bit(key);
     param->table->quick_rows[key]=records;
     param->table->quick_key_parts[key]=param->max_key_part+1;
-
+    param->table->quick_n_ranges[key]= param->n_ranges;
     if (cpk_scan)
       param->is_ror_scan= TRUE;
   }
@@ -5440,7 +5443,10 @@ check_quick_keys(PARAM *param,uint idx,SEL_ARG *key_tree,
       HA_NOSAME &&
       min_key_length == max_key_length &&
       !memcmp(param->min_key,param->max_key,min_key_length))
+  {
     tmp=1;					// Max one record
+    param->n_ranges++;
+  }
   else
   {
     if (param->is_ror_scan)
@@ -5460,6 +5466,7 @@ check_quick_keys(PARAM *param,uint idx,SEL_ARG *key_tree,
             is_key_scan_ror(param, keynr, key_tree->part + 1)))
         param->is_ror_scan= FALSE;
     }
+    param->n_ranges++;
 
     if (tmp_min_flag & GEOM_FLAG)
     {

sql/sql_select.cc

@@ -3335,7 +3335,10 @@ best_access_path(JOIN      *join,
       uint key= keyuse->key;
       KEY *keyinfo= table->key_info+key;
       bool ft_key=  (keyuse->keypart == FT_KEYPART);
-      uint found_ref_or_null= 0;
+      /* Bitmap of keyparts where the ref access is over 'keypart=const': */
+      key_part_map const_part= 0;
+      /* The or-null keypart in ref-or-null access: */
+      key_part_map ref_or_null_part= 0;
 
       /* Calculate how many key segments of the current key we can use */
       start_key= keyuse;
@@ -3347,12 +3350,14 @@ best_access_path(JOIN      *join,
         do
         {
           if (!(remaining_tables & keyuse->used_tables) &&
-              !(found_ref_or_null & keyuse->optimize))
+              !(ref_or_null_part && (keyuse->optimize &
+                                     KEY_OPTIMIZE_REF_OR_NULL)))
           {
             found_part|= keyuse->keypart_map;
-            double tmp= prev_record_reads(join,
-					  (found_ref |
-					   keyuse->used_tables));
+            if (!(keyuse->used_tables & ~join->const_table_map))
+              const_part|= keyuse->keypart_map;
+            double tmp= prev_record_reads(join, (found_ref |
+                                                 keyuse->used_tables));
             if (tmp < best_prev_record_reads)
             {
               best_part_found_ref= keyuse->used_tables;
@@ -3364,8 +3369,8 @@ best_access_path(JOIN      *join,
 	      If there is one 'key_column IS NULL' expression, we can
 	      use this ref_or_null optimisation of this field
 	    */
-	    found_ref_or_null|= (keyuse->optimize &
-				 KEY_OPTIMIZE_REF_OR_NULL);
+            if (keyuse->optimize & KEY_OPTIMIZE_REF_OR_NULL)
+              ref_or_null_part |= keyuse->keypart_map;
           }
           keyuse++;
         } while (keyuse->table == table && keyuse->key == key &&
@@ -3401,7 +3406,7 @@ best_access_path(JOIN      *join,
           Check if we found full key
         */
         if (found_part == PREV_BITS(uint,keyinfo->key_parts) &&
-            !found_ref_or_null)
+            !ref_or_null_part)
         {                                         /* use eq key */
           max_key_part= (uint) ~0;
           if ((keyinfo->flags & (HA_NOSAME | HA_NULL_PART_KEY)) == HA_NOSAME)
@@ -3413,6 +3418,23 @@ best_access_path(JOIN      *join,
           {
             if (!found_ref)
             {                                     /* We found a const key */
+              /*
+                ReuseRangeEstimateForRef-1:
+                We get here if we've found a ref(const) (c_i are constants):
+                  "(keypart1=c1) AND ... AND (keypartN=cN)"   [ref_const_cond]
+                
+                If range optimizer was able to construct a "range" 
+                access on this index, then its condition "quick_cond" was
+                eqivalent to ref_const_cond (*), and we can re-use E(#rows)
+                from the range optimizer.
+                
+                Proof of (*): By properties of range and ref optimizers 
+                quick_cond will be equal or tighther than ref_const_cond. 
+                ref_const_cond already covers "smallest" possible interval - 
+                a singlepoint interval over all keyparts. Therefore, 
+                quick_cond is equivalent to ref_const_cond (if it was an 
+                empty interval we wouldn't have got here).
+              */
               if (table->quick_keys.is_set(key))
                 records= (double) table->quick_rows[key];
               else
@@ -3433,6 +3455,23 @@ best_access_path(JOIN      *join,
                 if (records < 2.0)
                   records=2.0;               /* Can't be as good as a unique */
               }
+              /*
+                ReuseRangeEstimateForRef-2:  We get here if we could not reuse
+                E(#rows) from range optimizer. Make another try:
+                
+                If range optimizer produced E(#rows) for a prefix of the ref
+                access we're considering, and that E(#rows) is lower then our
+                current estimate, make an adjustment. The criteria of when we
+                can make an adjustment is a special case of the criteria used
+                in ReuseRangeEstimateForRef-3.
+              */
+              if (table->quick_keys.is_set(key) &&
+                  const_part & (1 << table->quick_key_parts[key]) &&
+                  table->quick_n_ranges[key] == 1 &&
+                  records > (double) table->quick_rows[key])
+              {
+                records= (double) table->quick_rows[key];
+              }
             }
             /* Limit the number of matched rows */
             tmp= records;
@@ -3461,12 +3500,50 @@ best_access_path(JOIN      *join,
           {
             max_key_part= max_part_bit(found_part);
             /*
-              Check if quick_range could determinate how many rows we
-              will match
+              ReuseRangeEstimateForRef-3:
+              We're now considering a ref[or_null] access via
+              (t.keypart1=e1 AND ... AND t.keypartK=eK) [ OR  
+              (same-as-above but with one cond replaced 
+               with "t.keypart_i IS NULL")]  (**)
+              
+              Try re-using E(#rows) from "range" optimizer:
+              We can do so if "range" optimizer used the same intervals as
+              in (**). The intervals used by range optimizer may be not 
+              available at this point (as "range" access might have choosen to
+              create quick select over another index), so we can't compare
+              them to (**). We'll make indirect judgements instead.
+              The sufficient conditions for re-use are:
+              (C1) All e_i in (**) are constants, i.e. found_ref==FALSE. (if
+                   this is not satisfied we have no way to know which ranges
+                   will be actually scanned by 'ref' until we execute the 
+                   join)
+              (C2) max #key parts in 'range' access == K == max_key_part (this
+                   is apparently a necessary requirement)
+
+              We also have a property that "range optimizer produces equal or 
+              tighter set of scan intervals than ref(const) optimizer". Each
+              of the intervals in (**) are "tightest possible" intervals when 
+              one limits itself to using keyparts 1..K (which we do in #2).              
+              From here it follows that range access used either one, or
+              both of the (I1) and (I2) intervals:
+              
+               (t.keypart1=c1 AND ... AND t.keypartK=eK)  (I1) 
+               (same-as-above but with one cond replaced  
+                with "t.keypart_i IS NULL")               (I2)
+
+              The remaining part is to exclude the situation where range
+              optimizer used one interval while we're considering
+              ref-or-null and looking for estimate for two intervals. This
+              is done by last limitation:
+
+              (C3) "range optimizer used (have ref_or_null?2:1) intervals"
             */
-            if (table->quick_keys.is_set(key) &&
-                table->quick_key_parts[key] == max_key_part)
+            if (table->quick_keys.is_set(key) && !found_ref &&          //(C1)
+                table->quick_key_parts[key] == max_key_part &&          //(C2)
+                table->quick_n_ranges[key] == 1+test(ref_or_null_part)) //(C3)
+            {
               tmp= records= (double) table->quick_rows[key];
+            }
             else
             {
               /* Check if we have statistic about the distribution */
@@ -3510,21 +3587,37 @@ best_access_path(JOIN      *join,
                 }
                 records = (ulong) tmp;
               }
+
+              if (ref_or_null_part)
+              {
+                /* We need to do two key searches to find key */
+                tmp *= 2.0;
+                records *= 2.0;
+              }
+
               /*
-                If quick_select was used on a part of this key, we know
-                the maximum number of rows that the key can match.
+                ReuseRangeEstimateForRef-4:  We get here if we could not reuse
+                E(#rows) from range optimizer. Make another try:
+                
+                If range optimizer produced E(#rows) for a prefix of the ref 
+                access we're considering, and that E(#rows) is lower then our
+                current estimate, make the adjustment.
+
+                The decision whether we can re-use the estimate from the range
+                optimizer is the same as in ReuseRangeEstimateForRef-3,
+                applied to first table->quick_key_parts[key] key parts.
               */
               if (table->quick_keys.is_set(key) &&
                   table->quick_key_parts[key] <= max_key_part &&
+                  const_part & (1 << table->quick_key_parts[key]) &&
+                  table->quick_n_ranges[key] == 1 + test(ref_or_null_part &
+                                                         const_part) &&
                   records > (double) table->quick_rows[key])
-                tmp= records= (double) table->quick_rows[key];
-              else if (found_ref_or_null)
               {
-                /* We need to do two key searches to find key */
-                tmp *= 2.0;
-                records *= 2.0;
+                tmp= records= (double) table->quick_rows[key];
               }
             }
+
             /* Limit the number of matched rows */
             set_if_smaller(tmp, (double) thd->variables.max_seeks_for_key);
             if (table->used_keys.is_set(key))

sql/table.h

@@ -221,6 +221,7 @@ struct st_table {
   ha_rows	quick_rows[MAX_KEY];
   key_part_map  const_key_parts[MAX_KEY];
   uint		quick_key_parts[MAX_KEY];
+  uint		quick_n_ranges[MAX_KEY];
 
   /*
     If this table has TIMESTAMP field with auto-set property (pointed by